I've had two computers in my diving career: #1: Mares Nemo Wide; #2: Petrel (1st gen; no compass).
Price:
Mares: ~$450, but had to pay another $100 for a cable so I could download my dives to my computer dive log
Petrel: ~$900, no additional cost -- wireless download included (I think Petrels go for around $750 now)
Visibility:
Mares: large but low contrast LCD screen, multi-segment display, information not clearly labeled, dim green temporary backlighting available; I have to peer at the display to see it, and it's not easy to decipher the individual pieces of information
Petrel: large bright LED pixel display, multicolor, well organized; I can glance at my wrist and immediately get the important information
User interface:
Mares: 4 button; I've had the thing for four years, and yes, I can use it, but it feels awkward
Petrel: 2 button: left button moves through options, right button selects. It's always going to be a bit awkward inputting information with only 2 buttons, but I find the Petrel intuitive and relatively easy to use.
Power:
Mares: 'button' battery, available at Walgreens (I'm sure any other place that stocks hearing aid batteries will have it). Change it maybe once/year. (diving ~6 days/month, 2 dives/day)
Petrel: standard AA battery; change it maybe once a month (same dive frequency)
For me the Petrel is one of my favorite pieces of dive gear. The ability to glance at the screen in just about any lighting conditions and see all the info I need almost instantly is it's number one advantage. I do cave dive, but thus far have never used more than 2 gas mixes, nor have I fiddled with the deco model settings, leaving them on the (relatively) conservative defaults. While the computer has lots of things you can change, including things like adding a gas mix mid-dive, these aren't things that you'd accidentally do. In tech mode it does assume you have some knowledge of what you're doing and won't enforce things like safety stops or missed deco stops, but you can put it in rec mode with a few button presses where far fewer options are available and it will enforce more safety factors.