You guys got me thinking about the importance of the boat you charter. I went out with Down Under who has a 40' Newton and it was a rough day for half the trip. However, once we got there we were the ONLY boat there! The other smaller boats cancelled. I am going back in June and July and was going to set out of Pensacola but I am thinking about using Down Under just for this reason. Do you think it makes much difference?
It's a crapshoot. I don't know any captains in our area that go out in forecast 3+ft seas. 1-2 1-3,
maybe 2-3, but that's the upper limit. Captains
want to run, otherwise they're not making money. If a captain cancels a trip because the forecast is iffy, and then things turn out to be good, he'll call everyone on the list to try to get the trip going again, but if he can't get enough of those people, the trip doesn't run.
Generally, if you're worried about iffy weather, you're probably better off with a 6-pack, as they're faster than the bigger boats, and they'll run with fewer divers, so they're more flexible with their schedules. You'll trade the comfort of a bigger boat for the time you save making it out there and back at a faster speed.
If you're in Pensacola and you're looking for a big boat, you can check out Capt. Douglas at
Charter Boat H2O Below - Scuba dive the USS Oriskany He mostly runs to the Oriskany, but he does inshore and combo trips too. Another plus with using Capt. Douglas, is that there are 3 other operations (all six-packs) that launch from the same marina, so if one Captain cancels, you have a better chance of jumping on another dive boat. They're all solid operations, with good captains and reputations.
My personal favorites:
Charter Boat H2O Below - Scuba dive the USS Oriskany 36ft Newton
Niuhi Dive Charters - Pensacola Scuba Diving Adventures 6-pack Cat
Other good ops in the same marina:
Dr Dive Pensacola, FL - Home of the USS Oriskany 6-pack Cat
Pensacola SCUBA Diving Charter Boat Dive the USS Oriskany Spearfishing Artificial Reef 6-pack Cat