Off-duty Mountie dies off B.C.'s Snake Island

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

I'm sorry to resurrect such a sobering thread, but does anyone know if Cpl. Voisine's autopsy was conducted, and whether it revealed the ultimate cause of the incident that lead to his death?

I used to live in the town of Grand Forks, BC, where Cpl. Voisine lived and worked before moving to the island. Now that I'm certified for diving I would like to know the whole story, and I can't find the information anywhere online.
 
Yes - there was an autopsy conducted, and a cause of death determined. However I am not authorized to release such information. I would suggest that you contact the B.C. Coroner's Service and see if they will provide you with any information. Sorry - can't be of further assistance.

Divegoose
 
Thank you.
 
I have received a copy of the BC Coroner's report on the death of Cpl. Voisine.

The official record of the incident itself corresponds with witness accounts already posted here. Cpl. Voisine was seen to be significantly exerting himself while donning his drysuit pre-dive, but he did not complain of feeling unwell.

The official cause of death is listed as drowning, with contributing factors including cardiovascular health conditions and hypercapnia (high CO/2 levels in the bloodstream), "due to elevated levels of carbon dioxide in the dive cylinder and excess ballast weight".

An autopsy found no sign of trauma or heart attack, though evidence was found of heart disease and a possible hereditary heart condition.

His gear was examined and found to be in good order, except that his ballast was determined to be in excess of recommended weight (45lbs of ballast and a total gear weight of 104lbs).

Most notably, upon analysis, the air in this cylinder, "was found to contain a level of carbon dioxide (CO/2) at 710.40(ml/ml3) which exceeds the acceptable level of 500(ml/ml3)", it goes on to note that, "Although Mr. Voisine routinely checked and serviced his dive cylinders, the investigation was unable to determine conclusively, where this particular cylinder was replenished with air."

According to his computer, Cpl. Voisine's rate of air consumption on his final dive was nearly double that of previous dives to the same depth.

From these facts, the report concludes that, due in some part to his medical history, coupled with the strain he was under from his exertions at the surface and being overweighted in the water, Cpl. Voisine rapidly consumed air from a tank with an unacceptably high level of CO2, which was itself under pressure and therefore concentrated, until he lost consciousness from hypercapnia and ultimately drowned.

The BC Coroner has classified this as an accident and has made no further recommendations.

PM me if you would like to read the report in full.
 
Last edited:
An accident? How the heck do you even get elevated levels of CO2 in a tank... Or was it CO?

CO2. I'm not familiar with the mechanics of the compressors used to fill tanks, or how such tainting of breathing gas could occur (CO2 is present in exhaust, so maybe if that found its way in somehow...?), but the Coroner's report notes that dive shops routinely have their compressor equipment tested for air quality, but that the industry is mostly self-regulated, although divers can examine a dive shop's most recent air quality tests prior to buying fills.
 
Remember that compressor filters convert CO into CO2 so exhaust or compressor oil burning could cause this.
 
Remember that compressor filters convert CO into CO2 so exhaust or compressor oil burning could cause this.

Right... So the Coroner's report is saying he drowned, but hasn't offered a reason as to why? Was he out of air? If it was observed that his breathing rate was nearly double, presumably this was brought on by the elevated CO2. An elevated CO2 level might have also exacerbated this vague heart issue he seemed to have.

Call me old fashioned, but I would hope that someone is looking into where he got his fills, 'cause it sounds like someone is pumping bad gas, and it might very well have played a role in his death!
 
Will an Analox CO tester detect CO2 as well?
 
Back
Top Bottom