Nurse Shark Attack!

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

I've lost the plot. Did the diver get bit by a shark and not just skin burned from shark skin burn? If bit by a shark, was it a nurse shark or a bull or what?

Post 11 contains information from the person bit. Post #14 and #38 from a person with him- #38 says Dr. confirmed bite, I think this is the person who speculated it was a bull shark (based on his own post #14) and the reference in post 11- it sounds like the person bitten doesn't know what kind of shark it was.
 
This was a great discussion that went everywhere. Thanks. Elena and I are checking our DAN insurance before we leave for Roatan.
 
It was me that this story is about, just got home late Saturday from 7 days in Cozumel. Had 3 days of diving and on friday went to Mr. Sanchos with dive buddy and wifes. Around 1 pm standing in water 10 feet from shore felt a strong bump just above waist, looked down and saw a 6" fish and then a narrow dark shark and he instantly bit me again but this time better. I pushed him away told my buddy who was close because we were talking in the water and started to get to shore. It swam away, my guess is it was after small fish and chased it into me. Also had a silver dive watch on left hand in water. He also saw shark and it looked more like a Bull shark. I was bleeding fairly well not in pain. They took me to front and called ambulance, some other people there were American paramedics and they helped untill ambulance arrived.I was released today around 10 to make my flight, required stitches. Doctor said looking at wound very sure it was a shark. Mr Sanchos came to clinic refunded my money and had wife sign papers. Mayor had a rep show also and expressed concern. Clinic did a awesome job helping me. All the people that got involved and took pictures confused me. $4300.00 dollars later I left. We dive Cozumel twice a year, I have seen many nurse sharks on dives in area and pretty sure this was not. Happened really fast.

It's simply amazing and both terrifying how fast a fish, be it a shark (non-nurse shark) or a barracuda or another marine predatory fish can strike so blindingly fast, they can turn and strike so quickly you have absolutely no defense and are in fact defenseless to their attack, there is just no reaction time to do anything and it's scary when you experience it and realize how defenseless you are.

You described a 'bump' which is disturbing if that is really what it was, or was it a failed strike at the fish that was near you? Typically it seems that when a shark bumps before biting something that indicates he was targeting what he was biting and the following bites were not accidental. The bump has been described by many bite victims as the precursor to the attack, indicating the shark is 'tasting' what he is thinking about biting.

If the shark did actually bump you prior to the bites this story is quite different then just a being in the wrong place while a shark was trying to attack a fish that was using you as cover.

Your description is confusing at what bit you, as part of it sounds like a nurse shark and part of it a non-nurse shark. A nurse shark is relatively slow and clumsy, almost dog like in their demeanor and certainly don't make lightning attacks, a nurse shark would more likely swim up to you and almost cling to you trying to get at a fish, you'd likely be pushing it away from you to get it away like "what the hell? Get off me!" Part of your description describes this almost exactly. But the other part about it making a lighting fast turn and striking you is not nurse sharkish at all, a typical reef shark or bull shark would certainly strike like this, with you never being fast enough to touch it at all. Perhaps the adrenalin and freak out typical of something like this is making you give the speed of the attack some extra speed then it actually was, because if you pushed the shark off of you, that's nurse shark behavior all day, and a reef or bull shark simply isn't clumsy and unless the thing was in a frenzy already it simply is not going to strike at a fish with two people in the water, sharks are very timid and wary of people, a nurse shark on the other hand, they are kind of the dumb redneck cousin of sharks that aren't too bright.
 
Mike, I've seen Nurse Sharks getting sharky and it is surprising how fast these mostly docile creatures can get. I've seen them get very aggressive including back and pectoral fin arching.

The striking part of this is just how rare it is. That's a good thing.
 
I think you're right Pete. When you combine that with his description of pushing the shark away from him, that sure sounds nurse sharky to me.
 
I have seen nurse sharks move lightening fast as well. I was taking pictures of a nurse shark laying under a ledge and apparently it didn't like my light shining on it and in a instant it spun around swam right between my legs (I yelled a couple of expletives into my reg) and was gone out of sight in just seconds. I was blown away how fast it moved and how agile it was. Pedro and the rest of the dive group especially my buddy thought it was rather funny after it was over.
 
It's simply amazing and both terrifying how fast a fish, be it a shark (non-nurse shark) or a barracuda or another marine predatory fish can strike so blindingly fast, they can turn and strike so quickly you have absolutely no defense and are in fact defenseless to their attack, there is just no reaction time to do anything and it's scary when you experience it and realize how defenseless you are.

You described a 'bump' which is disturbing if that is really what it was, or was it a failed strike at the fish that was near you? Typically it seems that when a shark bumps before biting something that indicates he was targeting what he was biting and the following bites were not accidental. The bump has been described by many bite victims as the precursor to the attack, indicating the shark is 'tasting' what he is thinking about biting.

If the shark did actually bump you prior to the bites this story is quite different then just a being in the wrong place while a shark was trying to attack a fish that was using you as cover.

Your description is confusing at what bit you, as part of it sounds like a nurse shark and part of it a non-nurse shark. A nurse shark is relatively slow and clumsy, almost dog like in their demeanor and certainly don't make lightning attacks, a nurse shark would more likely swim up to you and almost cling to you trying to get at a fish, you'd likely be pushing it away from you to get it away like "what the hell? Get off me!" Part of your description describes this almost exactly. But the other part about it making a lighting fast turn and striking you is not nurse sharkish at all, a typical reef shark or bull shark would certainly strike like this, with you never being fast enough to touch it at all. Perhaps the adrenalin and freak out typical of something like this is making you give the speed of the attack some extra speed then it actually was, because if you pushed the shark off of you, that's nurse shark behavior all day, and a reef or bull shark simply isn't clumsy and unless the thing was in a frenzy already it simply is not going to strike at a fish with two people in the water, sharks are very timid and wary of people, a nurse shark on the other hand, they are kind of the dumb redneck cousin of sharks that aren't too b


---------- Post added April 23rd, 2014 at 12:06 AM ----------

Like I said happened really fast. Standing there drinking, talking and watching clouds and all of a sudden feels like something has hit me below water. Look down and see fish and shark both a foot under top of water did not have mask so not a really great view but not what I expected. Hits again quickly, both times leaving bite wounds second ripping flesh with it softball size in roundness my belly button being the center of attraction. All i can think is to tell friend and people around there is a shark while trying to protect myself and get to shore having no clue what is next. I have had big catfish bite my legs in Oklahoma lakes while standing in water but it is no big deal, kind of fun. This did not feel like fun, way more forcefull and business like. Not what I had expected seeing a shark on me, happened fast and not a like I wanted to stand there and watch. Wish I had instant replay to review.Shark I say was aggressive at the least. Doctor told me day I left while cleaning wounds he would guess it was a small bull shark by teeth marks. Small is the big word for which I'm glad.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Z
 
Back
Top Bottom