I might suggest that gcbryan and doctormike ask maranda about her diving in detail. She claims to dive 30-40 ft with DCI-like symptoms, but perhaps she might occasionally hit 65 ft while spending most of her time at 50 ft? Just an idea...
I'm no expert but there are many things going on in a newer diver since everything is so new. TS&M makes the (good) point that once you are slowing your ascent and after you have a little more experience these things generally go away. TS&M mentions that for her she started using Nitrox and a slower ascent schedule and the tiredness went away. I generally still use air but did change long ago to a slower ascent schedule and that tiredness went away with me as well.
If I do 3 dives in a day in cold water (PNW) then I'm still tired but there are other factors in cold water. I think I have read where TS&M also tries to eliminate that third dive in cold water for similar reasons.