I dove Eden and many others during the day, and did many night dives just off the shore of Sunset House without any disappointment. We saw tons of nightlife (every night)...shrimp, HUGE lobster (10-12 lbs, easy!!), octopus each night, 5 foot tarpon that were following us and attacking fish off of our lights (they were swimming along side of us just two feet away)....I could have stayed there all night. Best of all, it was free...no charge for shore diving. Our last night at Sunset they chartered a night dive to a place we thought would be fantastic diving (because it was teeming with life during the day), but we couldn't go since we were flying the next morning....come to find out they didn't see anything there....go figure.