New Wreck off Lahina

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Here is a Newspaper article. They sunk it Tuesday

LAHAINA – West Maui will say au revoir to the
Carthaginian II Tuesday, when it will be towed to a
spot off Puamana and sunk for an artificial reef.

“This will keep the Carthaginian in Lahaina’s waters
where she belongs, while improving the quality of our
sub tour,” said Jim Walsh, general manager of owner
Atlantis Submarines Maui. “It’s a good solution for
the community.”

The Board of Land and Natural Resources completed a
lease agreement for submerged state lands on Friday,
the last of many governmental permits needed to create
an artificial reef from the veteran sailing vessel.

Atlantis has not much time to get the work done. As
part of its environmental impact review, Atlantis
agreed to a condition requested by the Hawaiian
Islands Humpback Whale National Marine Sanctuary not
to sink the ship during whale season, which by state
law begins on Thursday and runs through May 15.

The old ship is in such bad condition that there is
concern that a heavy south swell might sink it at its
moorings in Lahaina Harbor.

Such disasters have happened before. The first
Carthaginian hit a reef and sank as it was being towed
out for repairs.

Today’s ship, the Carthaginian II, was surveyed and
found to be in such bad shape that engineers doubted
it could be towed to Honolulu, the closest dockyard
capable of making repairs.

The Lahaina Restoration Foundation then sold the ship
to Atlantis in 2003, figuring to have it sunk on
purpose instead of by mishap. It has taken this long
to get the permits to do the work.

Atlantis has considerable experience in creating
artificial reefs. Off Waikiki, it has sunk an old Navy
tanker, a fishing boat and the hulls of two airplanes
to create homes where marine life can congregate.

Under nonexclusive leases of state submerged lands,
Atlantis can use the reefs as destinations for its
tourist submarines, but divers and even competing sub
tour companies can as well.

The site selected is 95 feet deep, about 3,100 feet
off Puamana Beach Park. There is no coral there now.

Later, Atlantis plans to construct a neighbor reef,
either finding other hulks or perhaps using engineered
structures.

“We take great pride in being stewards of the marine
environment that Atlantis works in, so we’ve been
committed to doing this project the right way,” said
Walsh.

“This artificial reef will have a very positive impact
on Lahaina’s marine life.”

The ship has already been cleaned of any hazardous
chemicals and will be stripped of any top hamper that
might create a hazard to navigation.

As the sinking date came nearer, a number of residents
and visitors expressed regret that Carthaginian II,
which had been a fixture at the harbor since 1973,
would no longer be there.

However, Carthaginian was never a real whaler. She was
a workaday cargo boat, doing nothing more romantic
than hauling fertilizer around the Baltic until she
was refitted with rigging to simulate a 19th-century
whaler and got a new career in Hawaii as a museum.

Atlantis has been running its submarine tour out of
Lahaina Harbor since 1991.

I am looking forward to getting out there on the site ASAP

Hope this helps

Ty Burnett
www.in2scuba.com
 
I can't tell from reading this thread: is this ship actually sunk now?
 
Al Mialkovsky:
I've crawled around below decks on it before so it's going to be cool to dive it. Can't wait and good to see you. Are you back on maui??? If so my buddy needs a friend as he's a DIR wannabe right now.

I'm still in Alabama ... Got to do my first cool/fresh water dive last Saturday it was FUN! I truly appreciate my drysuit now and see it's value ... Don't worry, I still appreciate Maui diving and should be back on December 29th.. working on my Nitrox course the 30th ... :D

First I gotta get up to Ohio and visit some friends... but alas no diving while there (would have been fun though)

Aloha, Tim

P.S. Have your friend contact me and we'll see about getting together.
 
I'm pretty sure he's gone before you get back Tim. Oh well.

44 degrees in the lake this morning, I love my drysuit too. My students loved surviving.
 
Hey, there's always next year. I have a feeling this is going to become a yearly event. As much as I love that 44 degree water, I've got to admit this is pretty nice.
 
I dove the Carthaginian last week. The wreck is pretty pristine, having been down only a month or so. It doesn't have a lot of sealife living in it yet. The cargo hold is wide open, and you can see the engine room pretty easily. There are a few spots of 'overhead environment', but not what I would call real penetration.

The most unusual thing about this dive was that a tourist submarine came by while we were diving. This is the first time I've ever been on display as a diver (since I've never dove in an aquarium).
 
Here's a picture of the stern.
 
Mark,

would you recommend it as a dive, or as one to wait a year or so before diving? Seems like the ops are definitely charging a premium to dive it though....
 

Back
Top Bottom