My encounter on Sat. Need advice on what to do if it happens again

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

eelnoraa

Contributor
Messages
4,114
Reaction score
1,076
Location
San Francisco Bay Area
# of dives
100 - 199
I went diving with an internet group on Sat. Overall, it was fun and uneventful. But now when I think about everything that happened, things were not too safe. Here was what happened in 1st dive:

First, there were some equipment issue. I rented things with a different shop than my usual one. There was no computer, just pressure/depth/compass console. I thought fine, I just use my watch as timer. Watch failed at about 30ft (those casio g-shock "200m" watch, unreliable). The compass was stuck but this part was my fault because I didn't fully check out the equipment myself.

All the above would probably not too big of a problem if my buddy would back me up or if viz were great. But viz was like 5-10ft. I paired with a "certified for 2 month" diver who either doesn't really care or over confident.

First, neither of us had computers. I wanted to take quick look at the table and to know approximately how long we should be under. He didn't think it was necessary because he thought we would run out of air before hitting NDL. I quickly glanced at the talbe and decided my limit is 50ft, and max bottom time.

Then, he didn't think buddy check was necessary. when I said "let's do buddy check", he simple said "you setup look OK". I insisted to check for air, alternative, releases and weight belts.

As soon as we descented, he started swimming, fast, using both arms and legs. I had to try my best to keep up and follow. Once a while, he would look back and wait for me, but in 5ft viz, he was out of my sight a few times. I had no compass and no timer, I was very nervous the whole time. We also lacked navigation skill. He led the wrong way and he realized it about 15 minutes into it . We ascented and check out out position, we were almost opposite of where we intended to go. We then descented again headed to our target location.

The rest of the dive was the same. He swam fast, I followed. At no time, I was looking around for sea lifes because if I were to take my eye off him for 30 seconds, he would be out of sight. The good thing was he led the right way this time and got us safely back to shore.

On the 2nd dive, I asked the organizer for a change buddy. The new boddy was a very experienced diver, we did buddy check, talk about where we would dive. I told him I have no timer or compass. We adjusted the dive plan. I felt much safer with this diver. But on this dive, the viz dropped to <2ft. We ended the dive early.

Now, I know I was responsible for equipment failure. I need to get myself a reliable timer/computer and compass. But what about buddies? what would you do if you realized your buddy's diving pratice after getting into water? Or am I being too paranoid about everything that happened?
 
Once you're in the water, the best bet would be just to thumb the dive if you feel that uncomfortable with them. It sucks when you're eagerly looking forward to the dive, but any buddy worth being a buddy shouldn't have any problem with you thumbing a dive at any time for any reason, and the enjoyment of their dive isn't worth the risk to you in pushing on in unsafe/uncomfortable conditions. If he/she has a problem with you thumbing the dive, then to bad for them.

I think in this case the first indication would have been that he didn't want to do a buddy check or plan the dive. If a new "buddy" flat out refuses to do that prior to a dive, alarm bells should go off.
 
OK, I'm a relatively new diver and hope I never become complacent but I have a very simple policy.....no buddy check, no dive. So far it's never been a problem & luckily I've never had such a cavalier "buddy".
 
You are not being paranoid ... you're being responsible.

First, ask your buddy to slow down (using the exact same signal the traffic police use when they think you're going too fast ... open hand, palm down, slowly pushing in a downward direction). If he does not comply, thumb the dive.

First off, you dive to have fun ... and it doesn't sound like you had much fun on that dive. So why do it? Second, it's stressful ... and stress isn't our friend underwater, since it takes your mind off what you're supposed to be doing and can set up the conditions for an accident. Furthermore, pushing yourself to keep up with him can lead to CO2 retention ... which can create a feeling like you can't get enough air ... and that can lead to panic, particularly in a new diver. It's a condition that's to be avoided.

If you had it to do over again, the time you surfaced to get your bearings would've been a great time to say "Hey, I really need to slow down."

Never ... ever ... extend a dive for your dive buddy's sake. If something about the dive makes you nervous, signal your buddy that you want to ascend ... and be emphatic that they ascend with you.

My guess would be that there was a little "voice" in your head telling you this wasn't fun and maybe it would be a good idea to end the dive. Next time, listen to that little voice ... it's trying to keep you alive and well.

... Bob (Grateful Diver)
 
Bottom line.. If your not feeling good about the dive dont do it. I would rather dive another day than take a risk.
 
Well, you have learned something about the way YOU like to dive, and the way OTHER people may like to dive. So next time, you will sit down with your "instabuddy" and say something like, "I tend to be a careful person. I want to have a dive plan, and I want to do a buddy check. Underwater, I like to stay fairly close together, and move slowly to look at small animals. Does that work for you?" And if the person is honest and says, "No," you can move on and find another partner.

It's everybody's right to dive the way they want to dive, but it's your right to find a buddy who is willing to do a dive you can safely enjoy.

I highly suggest an early purchase be a gauge of your own, though :)
 
No you are not being paranoid, a certified for 2 month diver should not be ignoring his training like that in regards to dive planning and buddy check,and swimming with arms and legs, he will burn through a tank quickly, so going the wrong way doesn't help, navigation skills take practice, so with 2 . Yes, a reliable bottom timer/computer with backup is essential gear IMHO, and you were right to explain to your new buddy that you didn't have a working bottom timer.
 
I would have called the dive with no timer. That's just how conservative I am. And it sounds like you have some good experience to use to make your future dives more enjoyable. Be adamant about the buddy check. I agree with Bob; the surface check might have been the end of it for me. At the very least, you did the best thing by requesting a new dive partner.
 
Fortunately the more you dive, the more buddies you will meet. Divers are like drivers, some are good and some bad.

It may be time to start thinking about buying a computer. If you buy one that is wrist mounted, you don't have to worry if the rental reg only comes with a bottom timer.

Keep looking for the buddy that works for you.
 
Under the circumstances, I, too, would have thumbed the dive.

What happened to you is not uncommon with insta-buddies. And, it is one reason to find good, compatible dive buddies.

Consider the whole thing a learning experience. You learned:
1. Check your equipment before you leave the shop or your home.
2. When you are assigned a dive buddy (insta-buddy), talk to him or her and get things squared away. If there are issues, deal with them before the dive. make a list of things you want to discuss with your buddy. They should include: maximum depth, maximum bottom time, the pressure you will turn around at, the pressure you want to have when you reach the surface, safety stops, out-of-air procedures, buddy separation procedures, signals, and entry and exit procedures. Your list will grow and become more refined. It is part of becoming a better diver.
 

Back
Top Bottom