My dive incident

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Glad you're alive. You might want to find a better instructor.

I wouldnt say instructor may be at fault or not, it sounds like he is still new to diving and needs experience. His SAC is probably still crappy, and he needs to learn to equalise faster to help stay with the group. The keeping the BC deflated upon ascent is the main issue i see here
 
Thanks a lot for the responses. To clarify, I am Nitrox and AOW certified. I had also been to 80 ft. before for my AOW class. I think I expected too much from the DM as my previous DM on my first ocean dive was totally different, along with the boat captain.

You can't count on anybody underwater except you, and your buddy if you've had prior training and diving together and trust him.

In fact, I'll go a step further, not only can't you count on the DM to keep you safe, you can't count on him even planning a dive you're capable of safely executing.

SCUBABoard is full of stories of DMs that took new divers into dark holes in the rock only to find that they exited at 140', or took inexperienced divers over essentially bottomless walls. These dives didn't always end well.

You and your buddy need to be able to safely plan and execute your dive from start to finish, including avoiding and/or handling any emergencies. If your DM shows you cool fish, that's great, however you can't bet your life on anything much more than that.

Terry
 
I wouldnt say instructor may be at fault or not, it sounds like he is still new to diving and needs experience. His SAC is probably still crappy, and he needs to learn to equalise faster to help stay with the group. The keeping the BC deflated upon ascent is the main issue i see here

Equalizing and deflating his BCD were never part of the problem.

The problem is that the OP is apparently not comfortable/capable of planning and executing a dive without the direct assistance of a DM or instructor - though he is OW, AOW, and EANx certified. Considering that being able to plan and execute a dive WITHOUT the assistance of a dive professional is the VERY ESSENCE of being a certified diver, I'd certainly say there's one or more instructors who "under-delivered" along the way.
 
I am a new diver with 12 dives so far, 2 of them being in the ocean. This past weekend, I went for the 13th and looking back, I am feeling very lucky to be alive.

You were under weighted but you shouldn't consider that what you just went through was a life and death situation (just to put things in perspective).

It was life and death potentially only in the sense that any dive can turn out that way. You simply were under weighted and were on a dive profile that you weren't ready for in the first place.

You need to think things through ahead of time and if you don't know the answer, ask questions until you are satisfied or don't do the dive.

...
When I tried to tell them what I had booked, they told me I was either going out on the 3 tank dive, or not! Being new, I was not comfortable with this, but against my better judgment, I accepted, thinking that I would just do 2 of the dives as I had driven 2.5 hours there the night before and stayed at a hotel. I just did not want to waste it.

Why is this even an issue? You either get to do one more dive than you had planned on doing or you can sit one dive out?

I sense that you are just out of your element and everything is worrying you. This can be a good thing as far as the worry if it is well founded but only if you react accordingly which may mean canceling the dives.

I started getting curious about the depth both as a new diver and also we were all on Nitrox and my two of my tanks 35%s and one 32%.

Are you certified for Nitrox?
Being the newbie, I put my trust in the Divemaster, thinking he would keep things safe for me.

Wrong move as has been explained. Be responsible for yourself. He will probably do his best but what could he have done in this case considering he had others to look after as well? I'm asking this question just so that you will think through the process.

...
I was weighted wrong with my new 7mm. I had 16lbs it was great for my 3mm, but not this one!

Did it not occur to you that weighting would be different for 7mm vs 3mm? At this point you should have just gotten out of the water. Remember if you are under weighted at the beginning of the dive you are going to be way under weighted by the end of the dive after you've used up most of the air (weight) in the tank.

Again, you just need to think things through beforehand.

...
Then, when I saw the 1200psi and still saw these people around 90+ feet, I just said, forget this I am going up.
...

I told them I was not doing any more dives for the day.

Good move coming up at 1200psi and sitting out the rest of the dives.
...
I am very scared now.
...

You shouldn't be scared or rather the fact that you are suggests that you aren't ready for the type of diving that you are doing.

As was pointed out there was little the DM could do. You need to realize that the whole point of becoming a certified diver was to become responsible for yourself.

It's good that you shared your experience with others. You should continue diving if it's something that you want to do.

Most of us were awkward on our first OW dives. You made some good decisions as far as coming up when you got down to 1200 psi. Many newer divers wouldn't have come up until they were also low on air.

Just remember that you are responsible for your safety. Try to find a dive buddy and bring him/her with you on your first dives or at least hire a DM to be your buddy.

Finding an experienced buddy should be your first task.
 
What did you think would happen on the ascent (when the tank is more buoyant) after you fought you way down to the bottom with way too little lead?

Why didn't you just go back to the boat and get more lead?

Why didn't you just pick up a rock from the bottom, so you could make a controlled ascent?

Did your instructor teach you how to control a buoyant ascent by flairing out?
 
From some of the things you've said (fearful of a 3rd dive, your perception of this incident was life or death) i'd say your mental state prior to even suiting up wasn't 100 percent okay to do this dive.

Instead of walking away from a sport that may bring you years of enjoyment i think you may want to find some locals who have more experience to mentor you in real world ocean diving -- there is only so much you are going to learn in AOW.

Also, instead of relying on the DM -- who in contrast to most novice divers' perceptions of them do not have godlike powers -- get a team of constant buddies going, dive with them often and then when you have an incident in the future (because if you dive enough s**t happens) you will know that there is a real buddy right there for you and vice-versa.
 
I am glad you are here to tell the story.

AOW and Nitrox certified in 12 dives is a bit TOO FAST for my taste. Learn to walk before you run.

My suggestion: find a GOOD Instructor / DM and do a Peak Performance Buoyancy class, then find a dive group / buddies and do another 30 - 50 dives with them before you dive "solo" to 90ft.

Oh .... and re-do the Nitrox class please ;)

AM
 
I am glad your OK.

Only 12 dives, two ocean and going down 100 feet with unknown equipment with no or unknown dive buddy, is not a good idea.

I learn something new on every dive. The most important piece of dive equipment is your brain. The most important thing in diving is you are responsible for you. Never give your power away to anyone. A good book is "Diver Down". It has short stories of diving fatalities and then provides explanation what happened and why and what poor decisions each diver made. Proper Dive Planning would have you not choosing to make this dive. You are responsible for proper weighting not the dive master, boat driver or anyone else but you. You have to take responsibility for your dive. Every dive, every time.

It is good to be a bit fearful. It can help you focus on good diving practices. Diving is awesome and I love it. I would suggest to dive slow and easy. Shallow depths, excellent experienced dive buddies, good equipment, good weighting, bouyancy control. You could take additional classes, OWA, Rescue, bouyancy etc.. These classes improve your knowledge, skills, experience, and will build confidence.
 
Shaking my head here,,,,,,
 

Back
Top Bottom