This may not be the right place to say it, but taking a DIR class is neither a guarantee of a lifetime of safe diving nor the only path toward that goal.
Why not start out by just setting a good example. Safe diving is about taking the time to think about your dive, making sure you have adequate and appropriate gas supplies, and practicing good buddy techniques. DIR is just a framework for developing those skills ... it's not the only way to achieve them.
People don't get led to DIR ... they decide to go there. Be a good dive buddy ... if she sees something in the way you dive that appeals to her, she'll be far more likely to decide that it's for her too ...
... Bob (Grateful Diver)[/QUOTE
I fully understand that many paths exist to become a safe diver. Dive planing, gas management, and skills are just a small part of it. I have never pushed DIR on anyone over the short time I have been involved in this type of diving but I have helped many fine tune their skill set. To see a average diver start a class and in one week come out a highly skilled, cofentent, and aware diver is very cool. Some take longer but many after a few months are, I like to joke, rock stars...lol..
It's a little different with your family. There is no question in my mind that my son will start off with this type of diving. I have built my team on land now I must in the water...lol... She will come around and when she does I'm ready with the gear and information needed to get started. She is also a good AOW / Nitrox / EFR diver but could be so much better then that. Understanding that some might not agree with my out look on diving but if we are going to dive as a family why not as a team....
So again never said if you not DIR then you are unsafe. I just want my family to have the highest level of training I can get. It could be PSAI, TDI, UTD, or even GUE but I feel the instructor really makes the class and I'm luckily to have some of the best so close.