I would suggest trying the Scubapro Seawing Nova fins.
See this thread from last year:
See this thread from last year:
Question - Fins for weak ankles (ankle joints replaced)
Hi, I'm based in the UK (North West/Midlands) and just getting back into diving after having a 10 year break due to operations. The main operations have been around my feet and I have had both my ankle joints replaced. This was due to athritis which I have had since I was 6, I'm now 45. My...
scubaboard.com