Unknown Missing diver in Indonesia, with body remains subsequently found in shark.

This Thread Prefix is for incidents when the cause is not known.

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

I’ll be heading that way on Damai 1 in December. I’ll ask Damai CD if he knows about what happened.
 
What kind of shark is that? Tiger? White?
 
That’s a tiger. Says here the body was still identifiable


Yes, that’s a head of a Tiger Shark. Seven foot Tiger Shark is a juvenile one. A mature Tiger Shark can get to twice the size of this one.

IMG_4734.jpeg
 
I've been diving in the Strait of Alor in 2015, it was a cruise on a boat named "Waow" because of its waow effect.
Some of the strongest currents i have ever faced...
Since then the boat burned, totally distroyed.
 

“An American woman, presumed to have been killed by a shark while diving in Indonesia, possibly died from a medical condition before any encounter with the predator, according to her friend.

Colleen Monfore, 68, a mother of two and a Michigan resident, was on what was meant to be a dream diving holiday - a seven-week excursion with her husband Mike - when tragedy struck on September 26, said family friend Rick Sass.

Just days into their adventure, Monfore went missing during a group dive near Pulau Redang island, reported The New York Post. Two weeks later, fishermen discovered a shark and retrieved human remains from its stomach, around 113 km away from the location of her disappearance. Authorities later identified Monfore through fingerprints, according to Sass, who has been in regular contact with the family.

“We do not believe this was a shark attack. Mike thinks she suffered some kind of medical issue in the water,” Sass told the New York Post.

Sass and his wife, Kim, who co-owned a dive shop for more than four decades, reviewed photos from the dive, engaged in conversations with Mike and analysed data from his diving computer.

Sass said that Monfore may have become separated from her group due to rough waters and was not killed by a shark. At the time of her disappearance, she was around 24 feet underwater and likely had half a tank of air remaining, according to the New York Post report.

"There was a down current at the turnaround site, but it was manageable. I've easily done 1000+ dives with this gracious woman. I don't believe it was the environment and certainly not a shark that ended her life,” Kim Sass mentioned in a Facebook post.

Rick Sass said, “They dove massive numbers of trips with us over 30 years. Bali, Philippines, Bikini Atoll, you name it. She knew what she was doing,” adding, “We used to call her ‘Saint Colleen.' She was an amazing woman. She loved nature and animals. I know she would have never wanted a shark to be blamed for this tragedy."

Sass also noted that shark attacks on divers were extremely uncommon. "And sharks are not that way. We've dived with hammerheads, tiger sharks, and bull sharks. You have to give them respect and be cautious, but they won't just attack you," he said

The circumstances surrounding Colleen Monfore's death remain unclear. Images from the scene show the shark cut open, with human remains in a black wetsuit nearby.

"The shark was caught, but it was not in normal health. I thought it had swallowed plastic or a fishing net. It was cut open to find the problem, and inside there were the remains of a woman,” told a fisherman, as reported by Asia Pacific Press.

Indonesian authorities have announced that an investigation is underway.”
 
I kind of thought it was an opportunistic feeding sort of thing. Odds of being swept away by rough conditions and also being attacked by a shark are just not realistic.
 
We were in Indonesia in Alor the week that this happened. I don't know if she was diving land based or LOB.....does it really matter? Alor is known for ripping currents with unexpected current change,up-wellings and down-currents on dive sites. We actually dived the site where she got caught in a down current. A dive guide saw what happened and went after her, but was unable to find her. Search and rescue came in and searched for her from the air and sea. Most likely scenario.....she blacked out and drowned. The small Tiger probably fed on her body when it floated to the surface. What was reported in the news about being attacked by a shark while swimming next to the boat is absolutely not true!!
 

Back
Top Bottom