Looking for a BP/W for my wife...

  • Thread starter Thread starter aa
  • Start date Start date

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

I am a woman and one of the few on scuba board that has dove with a plate and didn't love it. I really love my Dive Rite Transpac. Lots of similarities to a plate, in fact they make the same harness with a plate and call it a Transplate. But in and out of the water the Transpac is more comfortable for me.


Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
 
The easiest way I know of to shift weight lower without resorting to ankle weights is to use a Marseille-style rubber weightbelt favored by freedivers. The Marseille buckle is nothing more than an overgrown buckle like most men use on clothing.

MAKO Freedive Weight Belt

The advantage is you can stretch the rubber belt much tighter than with a conventional cam-buckle used on typical Scuba weightbelts. That allows you to wear the belt far lower without slipping off. No joke, they stay wherever you put them as if they are stapled to you — even on a no-butt geezer like me.

Edit: Definitely look at this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XwA8DL6-Ya0&feature=player_embedded

You can’t always depend on getting heavier steel tanks on charter boats or when traveling. You can compensate for aluminum tanks by bringing an extra cam band with one or two weight pockets that can clamp between the bottom and your BCD band(s).

Fore and aft trim is the biggie, but don’t ignore rotational trim. My ideal trim is between horizontal and about 15° up and to be face-down, on my sides, or face up in a mid-water dead-man pose with no air in the wing. That is where the weight of a stainless backplate can be most useful.

In general, I recommend limiting the amount of weight on a belt to no more than 10 Kg/22 Lbs. I arrived at that number by dropping progressively heavier belts while wearing a 2-piece ¼" wetsuit (in the old days when the rubber was US made and didn’t compress as much). That was my limit to feeling comfortable controlling ascent. Your mileage may vary. I also find that is about the limit for rubber belts so the weight itself doesn’t stretch it too much.

Ideally, I suggest getting in a swimming pool where you can help her shift weight until you find the sweet spot for her gear configuration. Move the belt up and down, move weight around on the tank (an Aluminum 80 is probably the worst case), and even play with ankle weights as a last resort (you can probably borrow or rent them). Weight pockets are great for tests like this even if you don’t use them later.

An experienced eye of an instructor or another diver “might” be useful, but I feel that both of you will learn a lot more by doing this yourselves. It is a simple matter of balancing displacement and weight. Talking to new divers, I sense the concept is intellectually understood even if they never heard of Archimedes' principle. However it is not intuitively understood. Until it is you will never be able to adjust your ideal trim with suit, fin, and cylinder changes. It will be time well spent.
 
Last edited:
I agree that it is not a BPW vs Jacket BCD issue. Even though a BPW is "customizable", there are only so many places to put weights and those areas are pretty much the same with each. Trim pockets on tank bands upper and/or lower if available, integrated weight pockets, weight belt and ankle weights. I can not think of any weighting options available on a BPW that you could not also do with her current jacket. It's just a matter of finding the right amount of weight then adjusting the various placement options until you find the one that works for her.

If she likes her jacket otherwise, it may be worth listening to the great advice about trim given by prior posters. If she is not happy with her back inflate BCD for other reasons as well, then maybe a BPW is the solution, especially if you think fit may be part of the problem. In that regard, they are much more customizable then a jacket.
 
After you find a solution to her trim problem, and if she is still not satisfied with other aspects of the back-inflate BCD, you might consider the small Freedom Plate Contour.

I recently helped a female friend convert from a jacket to wing. She purchased the small size Freedom Plate and the fit was amazing. It literally could not have fit better if it was poured on her back. The advantage over conventional plates that are designed for doubles is the plate is tilted at 3° so it nestles into the back to help distribute weight and limit relative movement. The shoulder straps also radiate from the center behind the shoulders so tend to “float around” less, especially on a small female.

Definitely sort out the trim issues before though. It gets too confusing to adjust to unfamiliar gear and figure out buoyancy issues when you change too much at once.
 
Last edited:
If you are content on buying a custom setup ill be selling my venture exp with a hollis aluminum backplate and hollis elite harness that has dive rite 16 lb dump weights. I built it for me and im only 115 lbs 5,5 so it should be perfect. Its only been used one dive in fl and four dives in bever lake Arkansas. Let me know and ill send pics

Sent from my LGL86C using Tapatalk

---------- Post added December 12th, 2013 at 03:18 AM ----------

ga6a7y4e.jpg


u9anydys.jpg


Sent from my LGL86C using Tapatalk
 

Back
Top Bottom