Lets talk ear plugs for diving.

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

What good reason is there for ear plugs in the first place, sounds like a solution looking for a problem to me.

If you have that annoying water in your ear after a dive feeling than there are easy fixes for that.

If equalizing is hard you are not doing it right and plugs will only make it worse. Or your sick so dont dive.

If your getting ear infectiong get a dry hood on your dry suit.

Am I missing something.
 
NorthWoodsDiver:
What good reason is there for ear plugs in the first place...
That is sort of like saying "What good use is a pony bottle?" As has been pointed out in this thread, if one has none of the problems that the ProPlugs address then there really are no good reasons for using them. But someone with cold sensitivity, for one example, might find that the $10 investment worth the gamble, what with an abundance of positive anecdotes from credible divers. My personal opinion is that the only valid criticisms are from divers who have tried them and either experienced no benefit or a negative benefit. I think Proplugs should have a money-back guarantee so that there is no risk whatsoever of feeling like one wasted their money. The cost of goods is miniscule and would be of no significant impact to the company and would foster impulse buying. I have lost at least 4 pairs over the last few years so they have made enough off me and other constant losers to absorb any satisfaction returns.
 
liberato:
I think Proplugs should have a money-back guarantee so that there is no risk whatsoever of feeling like one wasted their money.
I think they might not have that policy because of sanitary reasons. Same like you can't return bathing suits. KWIM? If someone can't afford to take a chance on a product that only costs $10, then how can they afford diving in the first place? I think that's the cheapest bit of dive gear I ever bought.:rofl3:
 
I cant remember the last time I posted here. As have been said, the DOCS PROPLUGS are the only brand Im aware of that are dive rated ear plugs. They are vented so that you can equalize going up or down in the water column without any squeeze.

a common misconception is that they help you equalize in some way. They do not. They only exist to keep from getting swimmers ear and to protect against that cold blast of water. I HATE when the cold water hits my ear drum when Im diving. THey keep out all but a trickle of water no matter how long you stay down.

I havent read the DAN article, and have never heard about the medical related cons. They do restrict hearing. Someone posted that with a 7mm hood and the plugs they cant hear very well. If your wearing a 7mm hood, you prob dont need the plugs. your hood should keep the ambient water warm enough to keep from getting that cold blast and water penetration or swimmers ear is usually fairly limited. IF your still worried about swimmers ear, ask yourself if you have that problem wearing a 7mm hood. I have never found that much water penetrates the hood. I do have to admit, that when I scrub boats in the early fall and spring, I like the plugs because i pull off my tri lam hood, I just towel dry my hair, do a quick swipe of my ears and Im done. No annoying wind chill down to my eardrum.

Yes, they are somewhat difficult to size. make sure the salesman gives you the time you need. The ProPLugs rep gives the store a set of demo plugs, some alco-wipes, and training on how to size and sell the plugs. If the guy/girl just says your about a small and hands you a pair, I wouldnt expect great results. make sure they size you and let you try on a few of the demo's. It would be a shame to let 15 bucks worth of ear plugs fall out when you hit the water. When properly sized, they stay in for the majority of people. all ears are different and they are designed to fit most people, but not ALL people.

Do they stay in? yes. Ive done roll ins, giant strides, back rolls, you name it. they stay in. you will feel the seal break once in a while when you move your jaw or change facial expressions. its not always a perfect seal, but it still beats all that water getting in.

the biggest con is that they are clear. Some have a little string connecting them together. the idea is that if one falls out you didnt lose it. to me if one falls out youve just doubled the length of the string and now it has a snag point on the other end. I think they come in diff. colors, but you have to order them. I painted red dots on mine, but had to keep re-applying the paint because it just comes right off.

all in all I love mine. I need a new pair because, well, i lost em. When I get out I usually stuff them up the sleeve of my wet suit. I decided to ditch the suit next to the boat and forgot they were there. if you find em, you can have em......
 
Debay777:
a common misconception is that they help you equalize in some way. They do not. They only exist to keep from getting swimmers ear and to protect against that cold blast of water. I HATE when the cold water hits my ear drum when Im diving. THey keep out all but a trickle of water no matter how long you stay down.
This is not a misconception. For some people they help equalizing - they do for me. Obviously everyones experience is different.
 
fairybasslet:
I think they might not have that policy because of sanitary reasons...
Yeah, but I was thinking of them just eating the returns, not reselling them. You are quite right, though, that if someone is worried about blowing $10, SCUBA is not the sport for them!
 
Debay777:
...a common misconception is that they help you equalize in some way. They do not.
For most people they do aid greatly in equalizing during the critical first 10 or 15 feet. You are in effect equalizing against compressible air instead of unforgiving water. The water is pressing the ProPlug into the ear canal compressing the air behind it against your eardrum. If properly fitted it can only go so far, though. Once the water then breaks the surface tension of the valve (for me this happens at about 1.5 atmospheres) the main effect is then in keeping a pocket of body temperature water in the ear canal as a temperature buffer as you mentioned. That in itself can aid equalization at greater depths (in addition to any air pocket that lingers). You point out how annoying a cold blast can be. Some people even experience vertigo and middle ear spasms. A comfortable middle ear is a relaxed one. A relaxed Eustachian tube is a patent one. The hearing attenuation is a valid complaint. I actually prefer less of the cacophony of exhaust bubbles and underwater noises yet have never felt that I could not hear adequately things like overhead boats.
 
I Too, use Doc's Proplugs!! I have for two years now, and I know they help me to equalize. I have had every ear issue you can have, untill I got a pair of these ear plugs.

For $10.00 bucks, trust me, it's worth it!!

Regards, George
 

Back
Top Bottom