well, I guess the pony would have been much better to have in the situation I was in... And the way my octo. was hooked to me incorrectly (I didn't realize the consequences at the time) it would have been better not to have it! :11doh:
I guess the best thing would be to have both, and have them both in good (no, make that excellent) working order, and clipped on in the best/safest place, etc. There's definitely a lot to be said for redundant/backup systems! Even though I had been diving for a long time, I was naive (no, make that totally ignorant!) regarding my equipment... Never once thought of anything going wrong with it!! Of course, I had never been on any of these forums at that time, either:shakehead