darylm74
Contributor
TSandM:I think one of the strengths of Fundies is that it is a class that focuses solely on basic skills. You're not trying to manage a stage (or even doubles, necessarily) or run line or do things in the dark. The class just presents the basics: Buoyancy and trim, non-silting kicks, air-sharing procedures, valve drills and SMB deployment. It teaches some basic gas management and an introduction to thinking about decompression. From what I've learned, it seems that these are the underpinnings of ANY technical training, and somebody who has them down is going to go into his first technical course ahead of the game.
Bob's concern about getting the checkout dives is a real one (I'm lucky, we have a resident GUE instructor in Seattle) but "passing" Fundies is only important if you are intending to do your further training with GUE. TAKING Fundies and mastering the skills is useful no matter what.
It wasn't an expensive course, but it was the best scuba instruction I've had yet.
EXACTLY! Getting instruction that improves my skills and prepares me for my goals, even if I don't pass it the first time, is what matters most to me. I believe that the instructor makes up at least 80% of it, but I wanted to make sure that the NAUI course structure also provided the other full 20%, which I believe the DIR-F already does, hence my original question. My concern right now is that I get back to the basics and the DIR-F or NAUI Intro classes seem to cover that. If they stack up pretty evenly then most like it is going to come down to who can do what and when since I'm sure they are priced pretty much the same. Once I get past the basics and into full tech diving, there are various ways I can go and I haven't decided which one I'm going with. I have NAUI with Chris, GUE with Bob or Brandon and then I have another one that teaches IANTD. As JimC said, it might be good to learn from various people, but first things first.
Once again I'm glad that everyone has been open-minded about my question. I was a bit worried about it turning into a flame-war.