how is the diving

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Another option in the Caribbean is the island of Saba. It is a truly unique destination. Safe, rugged landscape, beautiful diving and wonderful restaurants. The only reason it is an affordable destination is the complete lack of beaches.

The cost difference between Mexico boat dives and Bonaire/Caribbean shore dives is mostly negated if you tip appropriately.
Math has never been my forte, but am I missing something?:confused: When diving in Cozumel I am easily looking at $80/day for a 2 tank dive + tip. When in Curacao whether diving an unlimited tank package or a pay per use system it comes out a WHOLE LOT cheaper than boat dives-even when tipping generously/appropriately.....
 
That is what I was getting at. Diving is much cheaper per tank if done from shore or a couple boat dives followed by shore dives on Curacao or Bonaire vs. Cozumel. I don't think I was clear. I think we are in violent agreement!
 
Curacao is a lot like Roatan except less humid (and buggy). And there's about 50+ shore dive sites all along one side.

Most require a short drive in from the main road so a car is a necessity - unless you go with the previously mentioned Dive Bus. Downtown Willemstad however is a big tourism destination, some nicer resorts, beach front restaurants, the famous shopping district and some dive/non-dive resorts further east. Many have an affiliated/on-site dive operator. At five of them it's Ocean Encounters. I often recommend the Marriott in Piscadera Bay, it's one of the nicer Marriotts I've been to - has a good beach, pool complex, and a shore dive off their property with Caribbean Sea Sports.

The reef at most of the shore dives requires a short surface swim out - usually off a sandy beach often bisecting ironshore cliffs. The west side is much less developed, Westpunt has a few smaller resorts/rental complexes and a couple of restaurants. Many people stay at Lodge Kura Hulanda out there - it's on a great dive site - Playa Kalki - and Watamula - arguably the best boat dive - is nearby. Go West Diving is on-site there. Shore dive site list: Scuba Shore Diving Site Listing for: Curacao, ABC Islands We saw a lot of fish - probably more than anywhere on Roatan except maybe the south side, big Moray Eels, an occasional grouper and a few stingrays. At some sites turtles and a few squid also. Dolphins on the Seaquarium dive and once past our apt. in Lagun.

Cayman is probably in my top 3 for best diving in the Caribbean. And I've been to all the places mentioned by anyone previously except Saba and Cozumel. Lots of deep wall pristine coral diving and about a dozen shore dive sites. We saw a lot of turtles, tarpon, grouper, stingrays - esp. at Stingray City...lol. Some of the best boat dives are off NW Point or the North Wall, Big Tunnel, Orange Canyon, Trinity Caverns, Hepps Wall to name a few. Farther east Hammerhead Hill or Babylon are among the best.

Everything on Cayman is expensive. The CI$ is pegged at 80% to the U.S. $. A good meal for two can easily break $100. And most 2 tank boat dives are over $100. Many of the shore dives are off improved dive resorts so those are affordable and easily accessible - ladders/docks over the ironshore when necessary. It's actually hard to find tanks to take off their property for other dives though but there are a few worth doing - Smith's Cove and Cemetery Beach are two. You can rent tanks from Eden Rock downtown or Divers Supply in West Bay. If you stay anywhere along Seven Mile Beach at a resort or condo, the majority of dive operators have a free shuttle since there's no close diving off SMB. A few of these shore dives no longer exist but here's an indication of what to expect: Scuba Shore Diving Site Listing for: Cayman Islands, Caribbean IMO the best shore dive is Turtle Reef up in the NW point area.

I've recently done Turks/Caicos also but it was off the T/C Explorer so I have limited exposure to Providenciales (Provo). Grace Bay there is called one of the nicest beaches in the world - I can see why. The diving there seems mainly centered around the NW Point area - you can see - but not swim to - some of the closer sites. We dove a couple days there - some stingrays, a few turtles, lots of fish then moved over to West Caicos. More turtles, barracuda, there was supposed to be some really big grouper but we missed them. Also a lot of stingrays. The wall there is just covered with stuff down past rec depths. We also saw several smaller sharks and some huge Lionfish.

But the best diving was French Cay - a tiny deserted island 45mins. from Provo on a fast dive boat (Caicos Adventures has one). On every single dive we saw multiple sharks, big crabs, barracuda, lionfish, stingrays and there are also fish nurseries in the coral heads near the moorings. At night we also saw lobster and a lot of conch. One night the big pelagics were feeding in the ships lights, then the sharks fed on the big pelagics. All at the bow of our boat - 120' away.

Provo seemed generally as upscale and expensive as Cayman. It's also quite a bit smaller in population afaik - a lot more open spaces. There's one casino and some nightlife at a few clubs in the Grace Bay area. Awful airport, tiny, crowded and old. All the flights my group were on seemed to depart about the same time thru the four gates so that was confusing. There's wi-fi in the restaurant - we camped out there for a couple hours in the morning. A taste of what to expect near T/C (not my trip report) Saudio's Trip Reports
 
Though it wasn't on your list, have you considered Belize? Ambergris Caye has fairly easy diving and a good topside life and is very relaxing. I spent two weeks there on one trip and felt incredibly relaxed when I was done.
 
Of the places you listed I have been to Roatan, Cozumel, Turks & Caicos, and Grand Cayman. I just got back from Grand Cayman 2 weeks ago and I was sadly disappointed. The topography is beautiful but the amount of fish life was very low. It was one of my least favorite trips ever. If I go back to the Caymans it will not be any time soon and it would be to Little Cayman. GC was also lacking in color on the reefs. If most of your diving has been in Coz, there is no where near the fish life and color at GC.

I cannot speak of Curacao as I have not been there yet, but I greatly enjoyed Turks and Caicos. I have been to T&C twice. But I will have to say that like diversteve I was aboard the T/C Explorer. He pretty much summed up the islands we visited and which were the best. If you can afford the dollars for a liveaboard I highly recommend the Turks & Caicos Explorer at explorerventures.com . If you divide out the price per dive and all the food included it really is a great deal. And the T/C Exp boat is an excellent boat. Great setup for diving.
 
+ 1 for Bonaire. We have been to Bonaire for two, two week trips. The freedom of the diving there is our favorite part. This past November we went to Roatan for two weeks and were very disappointed in the numbers of fish and the numbers of species of fish. We did see more sea horses in one dive in Roatan than we had ever seen before, but very few fish on most dives. I know Roatan is not Cozumel, but they are not too far apart and the thing that we liked the least in Roatan was that a cold front came through the second week and there was no sun, high winds and temps in the 70's. In December 2010 we were in Bonaire and did a couple of boat dives. On one of those trips there was a guy complaining that there was nothing to see, I guess millions of fish and other critters equals nothing to him, but my come back to him was that I had just seen that the high that day for Cozumel was supposed to be in the low 60's, you will not find those temperatures in Bonaire.
 
if you want a "new place" to try - consider grand turk; mainly all boat / all wall diving; good viz (not fantastic like coz); good sea life (not fantastic like coz); no current; warm bath tub diving; dive sites are literally 5-10 minutes away; they pick you up on the beach in front of your place; manta house (tanya and katya proprietors) is the coolest and best deal in town (ask for jungle bungalow) and the most centrally located; blue water divers and oasis divers are literally half a block walk on either side of manta house; great topside vibe; take a day to fly over to salt cay (5 minute flight that goes no higher that 600 ft); richard the pilot is also half owner of the airlines; debbie at salt cay divers will handle all of your travel, dive, food needs; candy will rent you a golf cart; same type diving but only 50 people live on the "island that time forgot" i highly recommend it; diving in provo requires a looonngg boat ride; crowded boats ( 6 people max in g. turk - they use carolina skiffs); provo very expensive; crowded; just not my cup of tea; hope this helps - by the way, i am a coz freak; been going there since 1974; i personally choose coz over just about anywhere else---but you said you were wanting to branch out; also love bonaire - i lived in aruba for 5 years and dove bonaire lots - call bruce bowker at caribe inn; can't go wrong; also buddy dive is probably the most complete setup for divers i have ever seen
 
From a diving standpoint only, Bonaire is one of the best for the Carib. Little Cayman or Brac are right up there too. If you liked Roatan try Utila which is similar. If you are looking for the best warm water diving experience, the coral triangle in the south pacific is a step above the Carib. but it is generally more expensive.
 

Back
Top Bottom