Welcome to the world of desperate Halcyon Halo users!!!
I'm having the same issue with my two Halos (double tanks) and, so far, I found no a solution for this. I've used several different lubes and way to apply them with no good results: after few dive I get the pop effect, or 2 stages.
But I've found a bigger issue: After adjusting them and getting the recommended cracking effort, after few dive it become harder and harder, up to the point sometimes I've surface with headache because CO2 accumulation (more that 3 water inch of cracking effort vs the recommended 1 inch).
Another effect is that after some dices the poppet don't close totally the gas flow and I get an annoying small continuous flow of wasting gas. To avoid it I have to close the knob, but the cranking effort get harder.
The problem seems to be that the poppet lose lube somehow. Just as a very important detail: I'm using original Halcyon service kits. Another fact: They start failing since I've service it and replace o-ring
¿Could it be because o-ring in service kits are not appropriated?
Those are my related posts in case you want to read it (both are because the same problem):
Halcyon H75P + Halo (weird?) cranking effort
Unavoidable flow in Halcyon Halo (SP G250V) 2nd stage