+1 for Manta House. Right across the street from (and shares owners with) Sand Bar. If you like the locals scene, Sand Bar is definitely the place to hang out. Katia at Manta House was a fabulous hostess and looked out for my every need.
Manta House was much more island-life and closer to my taste than Osprey - which other than Mitch performing - put me in mind of plenty of places in Florida.
Dived with Oasis right down the street. (Not the one by the cruise ships) They were fine, but I'll also hit the water with Mitch and the crew at Blue Water next time. Night dived with Smitty, too, can't remember his shop's name, but I want to dive with him some more! He knows where everyone lives.
Makes me ready to go back now! The walls were gorgeous!