Horizontally in the pool. There is no compelling reason to do it otherwise. The risks for a single diver doing it once is amplified for an instructor doing it multiple times.Do you believe that CESA should never be taught by any diving agency ?
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
Horizontally in the pool. There is no compelling reason to do it otherwise. The risks for a single diver doing it once is amplified for an instructor doing it multiple times.Do you believe that CESA should never be taught by any diving agency ?
Horizontally in the pool. There is no compelling reason to do it otherwise. The risks for a single diver doing it once is amplified for an instructor doing it multiple times.
what's marketed as "Advanced Open Water" should more accurately be called "Open Water Part II."
Never. I always carry an AL19 pony so this type of a ****show will never happenThis question is mainly for advanced divers.
EDIT: Advanced = AOW certification but not necessarily Technical certification.
How often have you practiced doing Controlled Emergency Swimming Ascents (CESA) up till now ?
Do you practice them horizontally, vertically, or both ?
At what depth do you usually practice them ?
I assume that divers currently always keep their regulator in their mouth at all times, just in case.
I mention this because when I did my OW training with NASDS in the 1990s, we ditched our regulator but then were immediately helped up towards the surface (while finning frantically) by the instructor from a depth of 5m.
Any other comment on the ideal frequency and setting of the practice of this skill would be most welcome.
Is it possible to practice this too much, or not enough ?
What criteria would you use to determine how much is "just right" ?
I am slightly less incompetent than I was a year ago.I rather think a CESA is what you do when everything else fails horribly but you are not dead yet. Beats drowning. I don't think the "horizontal" practice stuff is worth beans, and I am confident the vertical practice is stupidly dangerous if it is done widely. Take a freediving class if you want to get better being underwater without a tank. That's my plan when I get through my higher-priority courses.
Interesting topic though. I assumed CESA was to dangerous to be commonly practiced, and now I know even experienced divers think the same thing.