Well I guess I have to chime in here as the first SCR diver to respond. And as I have encountered for quite some time, CCR divers don't understand why anyone would want an SCR versus a CCR. So I am not going to try and convince anyone one way or another. Choose the unit that works best for what you are doing and one that you can have confindence in, that at the end of the day you will be home happy and safe.
Choice of a rebreather is based on need, reliability and safety. For what I do, an SCR is perfect, safer and highly reliable. I get a gas extention ratio of 8:1 so if I carry 80 cuft of gas, it is like carrying 640 cuft of gas (only lighter and a heck of a lot less bulky). It is extremely quiet, only a small overboard discharge about every 60 seconds or so (depends on my breathing rate) and I have no problem with the unit scaring sea critters. The only piece of equipment that causes enough noise to scare any critters is the power inflator to my wing.
If I need a greater gas extension, I can carry stages that will easily plug into the RB that once again I get the same 8:1 extention ratio with. I have more than enough bailout for my buddy and myself to make it home. And I have a scrubber that on average gives me 10 hours, and could go more if I choose to dive it that long. DragerSorb is cheap, so I don't bother to test my outter limits on the scrubber time.
The gas is moist and warm to breathe, providing me comfort. The unit is simple to assemble and maintain. It does what I need it to do and safely. I can drive the RB with any gas mixtures I need, so it is highly versatile as well.
CrazyC
Halcyon RB80