- Messages
- 16,606
- Reaction score
- 5,387
- # of dives
- 1000 - 2499
First time to 60 feet
- Thread starter Luke Fosburg
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
Dave Bevan
Contributor
This guy really saying that a pony is safer than manifolded doubles or sidemount?
Better tell all those tech divers they are doing it wrong...
Maybe go back and read the thread, if that's what you think that I was saying.
So how did the deep dives go?
I may have missed an update did not read through all the post. When I did my deep dives in Maui 100' I did feel a little narc'd but no big deal though I had some anxiety before but when I got to depth it was no different feeling than 30' especially with 100+ viz. Hope it went well and the wrecks were awsome fo you.
halocline
Contributor
I'm not a fan of pony bottles either, because I think they frequently are used as "feel good" devices that allow OW divers to either stray into solo diving or aggressive enough as to be pushing into technical diving situations, without actually training for these environments. Of course every pony bottle user in the water denies that he is doing that, but......
OW, recreational diving is based on the buddy system and immediate access to the surface. Technical diving is based on the presumption that problems need to be solved under water, possibly by yourself, and as such nobody would ever sanely dive in these conditions without full redundancy in any critical system.
A pony bottle doesn't really solve any problems in either of those environments. It's useless in the technical dives (you need full redundant tanks) and you should never need one in OW diving, IF you are diving safely with immediate access to the surface and a buddy. Of course, there is a grey area between OW and tech diving; like a swim through at 100 feet, or diving on a boat with a bunch of strangers who turn out to be unreliable buddies. Ponies seem to be suited to this kind of diving, and IMO they don't make it any safer. At least, I doubt there are any statistics that demonstrate additional safety. Hence, the 'feel good' label. They make divers feel safer.
But if someone really is concerned about diving safely, the answer is avoid unsafe OW diving or at least treat dives like that more as technical dives, which means advanced training. Lots of people won't like that opinion, but oh well.
I own a pony bottle, I have used it exactly once on a dive, and now it serves as a tire filler and regulator servicing aide. Maybe some very well trained traveling divers have legitimate use for one, where full technical gear (i.e doubles) is unavailable.
OW, recreational diving is based on the buddy system and immediate access to the surface. Technical diving is based on the presumption that problems need to be solved under water, possibly by yourself, and as such nobody would ever sanely dive in these conditions without full redundancy in any critical system.
A pony bottle doesn't really solve any problems in either of those environments. It's useless in the technical dives (you need full redundant tanks) and you should never need one in OW diving, IF you are diving safely with immediate access to the surface and a buddy. Of course, there is a grey area between OW and tech diving; like a swim through at 100 feet, or diving on a boat with a bunch of strangers who turn out to be unreliable buddies. Ponies seem to be suited to this kind of diving, and IMO they don't make it any safer. At least, I doubt there are any statistics that demonstrate additional safety. Hence, the 'feel good' label. They make divers feel safer.
But if someone really is concerned about diving safely, the answer is avoid unsafe OW diving or at least treat dives like that more as technical dives, which means advanced training. Lots of people won't like that opinion, but oh well.
I own a pony bottle, I have used it exactly once on a dive, and now it serves as a tire filler and regulator servicing aide. Maybe some very well trained traveling divers have legitimate use for one, where full technical gear (i.e doubles) is unavailable.
