Haven't read all of the posts, but a couple of things. It was apparent to me from the surface shots that the water was moving along pretty swiftly. While the surface can often move more rapidly on the surface compared to the subsurface due to wind and such, it did not appear windy, and the group was really stretching out prior to descent. I would have thrown out a line for the divers to hang on until I got everyone in the water and ready to go. Based on the bubbles, there was a fairly solid down draft. You do not need full on downward bubbles to have a solid downdraft. I think it was a solid pull here, especially for young and/or inexperienced divers. Not raging, like I have seen in Sabang and at Peleliu Cut, but strong enough to cause problems. Many lessons here, and I think the dive guide could learn a few as much as anyone. Was that the guide bolting down into a ripping current without looking back, while he had divers struggling to descend? Always good to gather everyone at 30 or 40 feet. Anyway, swim out from the wall, inflate and kick, be ready to deflate, do a controlled ascent, and, depending on conditions (yours and the site), either continue the dive or do a nice long safety stop. I certainly would have attempted to drop back down for the safety stop, as pops did, assuming my buddy was over the panic.