ear plugs in diving?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

We have our first "ProEar" student now. Together with his ENT Doc, we're all learning how to effectively use this mask, including keeping the ear canals from filling with water even during an accidental flood. (with good head position and no increase in depth) All is going well - looks like the folks who developed the ProEar have a winner.
Rick
 
Dear Rick,
If you forward me your email, I will be pleased to send you a lot of information on the ProEar mask and how best to use it effectively. The same for any other Scuba Board member
or user. We invented the ProEar and have thousands of hours of experience using this mask.
Howard
info@proear2000.com
 
Thanks, Hman,
Love to get any info.
murchison@bellsouth.net
Rick
 
This is a verbatim quote by Dr Chris Edge of the UK Sport Diving Medical Committtee on the BSAC forum;

http://www.bsac.com/membforums/depthforum/posts/1512.html

"According to the literature, it took a lot of people, including diving physiologists, to design this mask. A great pity, then, that they don't understand the fundamentals of ear physiology. It would be interesting to hear how they think that a tube from the nose to the exterior of the tympanic membrane mimics the Eustachian tube which, as everyone diving knows, connects the nose to the INTERIOR of the Eustachian tube.

If the diver has a problem with blockage of the Eustachian tube, the mask is useless. The air at pressure still cannot get into the middle ear, unless the tympanic membrane is perforated. It remains a closed system pneumatically.

Personally, I think that someone ought to be informed that false claims are being made by these people as is clearly evidenced from their website. I'm more than happy to debate this specific issue".

- - -

I good idea but I am afraid I have to agree with Chris :(

(apologies for the plagiarism, Chris!)
 
Dr. Thomas,
In all due respect, no one involved in the ProEar product ever claimed that the mask will help a diver with a blocked Eustachian tube. This condition cannot be helped and no one with it can or should dive. Other than that, I honestly do not understand what is false or missleading in the promotional material.
The tube connecting the mask to the ear cups transfers air and ambient pressure from one airspace to another similar to the Eustachian tube, what is wrong with this?

In reality approximately 10,000 divers worldwide have been using this mask since it first came out in July 2000. The response both by the professional and sport diving community has been incredibly positive as can be witnessed in the unsolicited testimonials we receive every week https://www.proear2000.com/pages/testimonials.asp
or by reviewing comments posted on this very board
http://www.scubaboard.com/search.ph...hid=5161&sortby=lastpost&sortorder=descending

If we have indeed printed or advertised anything wrong or misleading then we will immediately apolgize and retract it.

Have you personally seen or tried the ProEar mask?

Best wishes
Howard
 
Howard,

From your website,

"This allows the air space in the ear cups to equalize according to ambient pressure. The mask, ear cups and indeed the entire respiratory system become a closed circuit equalized air pressure system.

"The ear cups serve as a primary filter of ambient water pressure from the sea and the tubes mimic the Eustachian tubes allowing the diver to easily equalize the pressure in the ear cup before it ever reaches the ear drum.

"All the diver has to do is gently blow air through his nose to keep the ambient pressure (taken from the regulator) into the mask and ear cups. This creates a kind of 'Buffering' effect which basically allows the ears the equalize in 2 stages. The first from the sea pressure into the ear cup and the second from the ear cup onto the ear drum.

"The action of the silicone tube mimics the Eustachian tube but transports air in a much easier less obstructed fashion."

----------

Much of this may, possibly, be true in a strictly literal sense.

However the terms "equalisation", "eustachian tube", " ambient pressure" and "closed circuit" are all associated in the minds of novice divers (and many not so novice) with middle ear equalisation. These terms, therefore, strongly suggest that the Proear will assist with middle ear equalisation which it clearly does not. :upset:

There may be a neccessity for certain divers to keep their external ear canals comfortably dry and this device appears to achieve that objective. :) Indeed it may permit divers suffering with recurrent otitis externa or a chronic tympanic membrane rupure to dive in relative safety because little or no water will enter the middle ear, :) but I can think of few other uses for it.
(I am not recommending this use for it by any means! On the contrary)

Howard you ask "Have you personally seen or tried the ProEar mask?"

The answers are "yes" and "no", which brings me to ask, as an experienced diver (and potential customer!) with no ear or equalisation problems what benefits it could bring me?
 
Dr. Thomas,

Our position based on personal experience and anecdotal testimony from hundreds of divers is that indeed the ProEar mask does make equalizing easier. This may be due to the fact that the ear drum is equalizing against an ambient air environment as opposed to sea water. In any respect there have been too many people who have reported this benefit to dismiss it out of hand. Granted it will not solve all equalization problems and surely not those related to blocked Eustachian tube but the empirical evidence is too strong to be ignored.

The two benfits that you were kind enough to confirm,
1. Helping divers avoid external ear infections
2. Allowing divers with perforated ear drums to dive
are significant in their own right and should not be diminished in their importance.
There are a lot of professional divers (instructors, divemasters and commercial divers) who had to give up their careers for these very problems. Now we are getting more and more letters from diving professonals and sport divers who have returned to diving due to the ProEar mask. Some have even written to this and the Rodale Board to report this. If you like I can quote them for you.

As an experienced diver who does not suffer from chronic ear problems or equalization problems permit me to relate my personal story. I have been diving professionally for over 30 years with well over 10,000 dives and honestly never have had a serious problem with my ears. When I became involved in the project I honestly doubted if I would ever use this mask outside of the testing and R and D period (which took 5 years).

Today I will not go diving without it. Simply because it is so comfortable. I can't stand having saltwater in my ears anymore and honestly as a physician you will agree with me that polluted, cold saltwater under pressure is really not the best thing for your ears is it?

One other nice benefit of the mask is the directionality of sound underwater which can be especially helpful for divers diving in busy boating channels etc.

I doubt if DAN Europe would be endorsing and selling this mask on their website if they did not find it to be a helpful and useful piece of equipment. I can also go on by quoting some of America's, Europe's and Israel's formost Hyperbaric and ENT diving specialists but I think we have enough here to give the ProEar a chance.

I will be happy to supply you with one for your personal testing and evaluation.

Howard
 
Not to be accused of ignoring the evidence, Howard, I'll take you up on that!

I must say though, to doctors like myself and Chris Edge the website reads like psuedoscience. I will most certainly give you an unbiased opinion and if it works I'll try and give you an explanation that is believable.

I am afraid I cannot get the "priavte meesages" on this site to work so send me an email (address on my profile) and I'll get back to you.

Best wishes,:jester:
 

Back
Top Bottom