Neurolyse:A closed circuit rebreather is a lot like a twin engine turbo prop. Great machine. You can do a lot with it, but if you don't pay attention, it will fly you into the ground at a high rate of speed. With the additional capability comes more responsibility. On the other hand, although there are more ways to get into trouble with CCR, there are also more ways to get out of trouble as long as you recognize that you are in trouble.
Given the complexities of both RB/OC diving it makes sense that standard protocols need to be ingrained into a diver's brain prior to splashing in.
From day one ( training ) I examine attitude and try to develop permanent procedural habits in the diver's brain. Attitude is everything here. A rebreather diver doing a pool check without scrubber indicates a diver who may have shown a degree of complacency because they were not in an opewater environment? It also shows a failure to follow a hard set of protocols. You don't forget scrubber if you follow the protocol. At some point in that diver's training a learning gap existed, and was not addressed by the user, and possibly the instructor. Trust me, as a CCR instructor you have to stay on top of your new divers and use whatever methods are available to get them to internalize self-regulatory diving methods.
If one were to scaffold, or place the learning pieces in a hierarchy the average viewer would be amazed at the complexity and levels of steps needed to just get into the water.
X