Down sides to bp/w

[Longstocking]

I'm looking into buying some equipment. What I'm wondering is this :

Are there any down sides to a bp/w set-up for a newbie diver?

 

[Walter]

It's like any other BC, it depends on exactly which one with exactly which "features." Some BCs are well designed and well made. Others are not. There is nothing wrong with the concept. A well designed BP/wing works quite well for anyone of any skill level.

 

[RICHinNC]

Walter about said it all.

Just watch your costs. Some are also very overpriced.

 

[kidsdream]

First I should say I converted to BP & wings a year or so a go and would never go back . I actually have two set-up (one for travel and cold water diver & on that I keep down in the Keys).

The only potential issues is that depending on your exact rig and if you use a integrated weight system (like the Dive Rite or Halcyon systems) there is minimal room to add a storage pocket . Not a big issue, but it bothers some people not having a pocket.

 

[TSandM]

If you use the continuous harness, there is some practice involved in getting in and out of it. I've found that I have great difficulty taking my rig off unless I can find something to support the tank while I do so (a dive buddy, if nothing else is available )

As previously stated, there aren't any pockets. You can buy pockets to put on the webbing, or you can add pockets to your exposure protection. You can buy and glue on pockets for a dry suit, or sew pockets to a wetsuit or use something like X-shorts, which is what I do.

Otherwise, I think it's all up side.

 

[kidsdream]

If you use the continuous harness, there is some practice involved in getting in and out of it. I've found that I have great difficulty taking my rig off unless I can find something to support the tank while I do so (a dive buddy, if nothing else is available )
.

A Dive Rite Transplate allows you to get in and out easier and his adjustable.

Use them with both my plate rigs.

 

[CompuDude]

I'm looking into buying some equipment. What I'm wondering is this :

Are there any down sides to a bp/w set-up for a newbie diver?

Sure: Here's the downside. Your gear will get old. It'll still work perfectly, and won't need to be replaced, but it'll be OLD. Eventually. If you're the type who wants shiny new gear every year, that's a waste. But if you want an investment that will outlast any BC, bp/w will rock. Plus all the other benefits.

In all seriousness, the only downside I can think of to bp/w is the afore-mentioned lack of pockets. That actually annoys me more than anything else. Of course, I can buy a pocket and slip it on the belt, I just haven't yet. Cuz I'm lazy. So it's my own fault, as much as the bp/w's.

 

[MSilvia]

One other possibility, from my wife's experience.

If you were trained in a jacket, have only ever used a jacket, and are a brand new diver who isn't yet totally at ease underwater, you might find it a good idea to develop that comfort in familiar equipment before trying to make the switch... just to avoid the task loading that adding or changing anything might introduce.

Obviously, that's not a problem for everyone, but it's worth considering. If nothing else, you might want to try it a few times before you commit to buying.

 

[Hoosier]

I think it is totally personal preference. For the rec divers, BP/W rig can be hassle due to the unavoidable adjustment steps, cost, and more knowledge required (due to its flexibility itself). BP/W must be very versatile and flexible design, but some rec. divers don’t appreciate its advantages. For example, when you buy a car, some consumers like the option that can be chosen one by one, others just want a package deal or pre-set up deal. My opinion is that the rec. diving should be fun with less hassles. That’s the reason why many manufactures are working hard to develop their products.

 

[Footslogger]

Sure: Here's the downside. Your gear will get old. It'll still work perfectly, and won't need to be replaced, but it'll be OLD.
========================================
Same can be said about a standard jacket style BCD if it is used with care and well maintained. Not an exclusive characteristic of one style versus another.

'Slogger