Dolphin Slaughter in Japan

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I totally agree. Their market is subservience - the culture of not questioning your betters. Of course that presumes that your betters are actually....better - and not just out to shaft you.

If you know a way to get food samples to a lab that can analyze, from where I am in Kyushu, I'll make you a deal. If whale or dolphin comes on the school menu here I'll personally grab some and send it off. I'll also check shops etc when I'm in Fukuoka (not that often) and do the same if I see it for sale.

Let me know how I could do it - how to pack, where to send etc...... and it's done. Really.


Egads it is annoying!!! You can only dive at fisherman approved points, during fisherman approved hours. and each and every day of diving requires all divers to pay a small donation* to the local fishermans union.

* read: illegal but accepted extortion bribe


Very interesting observations about the village. Seems they are not doing so well? Does the village look like it’s prospering? I imagine that adult-age children don’t stick around too long. Haranguing divers for paltry diving fees is pretty cheesey. Seems they are trying to reap maximum reward from the only occupation and resource they know. Personally, I hope their fisheries collapse and they need to move on to something else vs. the exploitation of the whales. On a related fact, fishing, and whaling ghost towns are a fact in the Northeast United States. New Bedford, Gloucester, MA, etc. aren’t exactly thriving cities. Sad realization by these folks that some fisheries are not sustainable - even by a very shaky demand for product.

It’s an interesting proposition Kim. I’ll chat with a pal who works with a regulatory body here. I’ll also look into FDA & USDA procedures regarding testing. I would imagine that a parallel organization exists in Japan, and that data must exist somewhere regarding bio-accumulated toxins? I would imagine Greenpeace and Sea Shepherds having some data? What’s irksome is the fact that they are serving “kujira” in school lunches. Kids are an innocent population. They can’t handle much in the way of food toxins. Wow! :confused:


Interesting article related to toxins - Japanese schoolchildren fed toxic dolphin meat | Special reports | Guardian Unlimited
 
Just doing some research here. Seems there have been numerous analyses of dolphin meat in Japan. This was expected. The Health Ministry has already established guidelines regarding consumption.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2003/05/030520082803.htm

The interesting aspect is the intentional mislabeling of dolphin meat, lack of media exposure, lack of enforcement, some level of protectionism for the villagers (assumed) and some very dirty, very ugly stuff going on in the food trade. None of this data is any new news here. The only new aspect for me is the fact that no one is speaking up about it. As it has been implied - subservience is something which is understood in Japanese culture. Councilmen who have strayed from the party line (anti-harvesting) have been shunned.

School officials that allow whale/dolphin meat to be served in school are playing Russian Roulette with the kids. How do they sleep at night?

X

p.s. it'll take another Minamata.
 
Valid points everyone.

But if the demand for the meat is low, how come they keep killing the dolphins? Also, is there any environmental organization in Japan that is against this? Maybe they can help a lot.

If dolphin hunting is their only source of livelihood, then presenting another source, such as using their boats for tourism purposes will certainly give them more income.

Is all of Japan shutting their eyes and ears to this due to the subservience culture? If so, then we do have a difficult battle ahead.
 
Valid points everyone.

But if the demand for the meat is low, how come they keep killing the dolphins? Also, is there any environmental organization in Japan that is against this? Maybe they can help a lot.

If dolphin hunting is their only source of livelihood, then presenting another source, such as using their boats for tourism purposes will certainly give them more income.

Is all of Japan shutting their eyes and ears to this due to the subservience culture? If so, then we do have a difficult battle ahead.
I think you might be slightly misunderstanding exactly what the situation is. I'll try to explain it as I understand it.

Something over 20,000 dolphins a year are killed in Japanese coastal waters. By far the majority of those are actually bycatch in general fishing. This happens in any fishing anywhere in the world and isn't unusual AFAIK.

Two towns are left that have hunted dolphin for part of the year. There's a total of around 30 boats (read families) that do this. They don't only survive on dolphin fishing - they fish other stuff too - but they have a government allowed quota to actually hunt and catch dolphin during the season. The main income from that hunt is the sale of live animals to aquariums and marine parks worldwide. This isn't that many animals - but it's most of the money. The rest they kill and eat themselves, or try to sell on to a larger market. That market is shrinking so it must be getting more difficult - and prices will be taking a hit too I presume. Last year, they couldn't even sell what they had for human consumption so some ended up in pet food. This year, even shops that used to sell it are stopping because of the high content of mercury that's been found in the meat.

Why do they still do it?

Hard to say for certain but my guesses are:
  • They still have buyers for the live animals.
  • They see it as their "culture".
  • They aren't about to let anyone else tell them how they have to behave and live.
  • They're simply used to it. It's been going on for so long that when the season rolls around that's what they do.
  • They view dolphins as pests that compete for the other fish.
Is there anything that might stop them?
  • They lose the market in live animals. (Unlikely at the moment)
  • The market for dolphin meat collapses. (A good possibility)
  • The mercury issue gains in importance until the government steps in. (Actually quite likely IMO)
  • They realize, or are taught, that the money they can make from eco-tourism is more than they make now. (This has already happened in other places, so there's no reason to suppose it can't here)
What won't stop them and are probably simply counter-productive and causing not just the fishermen, but also the guys in Tokyo to not even think about the situation in a logical way, are the kind of protests going on to date. They're actually a complete waste of time and do nothing to help people like the counsellors in Taiji who tried to raise the mercury issue. One of the main reasons they didn't get further is simply that their "protest" got lumped with the foreigners "protest" and therefore discredited.

In the end though - even if they stop the official hunt, dolphins will still get killed - simply because they eat fish and the fishermen don't like them. As I already said - they're viewed a bit like wolves of the sea here....and are therefore pests.
 
Thanks for the informative post Kim.

It has been established that we cannot dictate what they should and shouldn't do, and that protests aren't going to work either.

If they kill these dolphins for self consumption, it is strange that they need to kill 2,400 just to feed themselves or to get rid of sea wolves. If the demand is super low, then most of these dolphins died for nothing. Nobody will eat most of the meat, it will eventually spoil, and then what? Just throw them away?

So, the main question now is that, how do we educate these people to make them realize that they can earn more in terms of eco-tourism? Are there any environmental organizations in Japan willing to do this?
 
I'm really not sold on the viability of this eco-tourism thing.

There are plenty of better places in Asia and Japan to go and watch dolphins play than Futo and I don't think big numbers will pay to go and watch in the dirty smelly fishing boats.... I sure as hell don't think the fishing families will invest big money in setting up dolphin watching boats... they get thousands of divers a weekend already and the facilities are still poor.
 
I'm really not sold on the viability of this eco-tourism thing.

There are plenty of better places in Asia and Japan to go and watch dolphins play than Futo and I don't think big numbers will pay to go and watch in the dirty smelly fishing boats.... I sure as hell don't think the fishing families will invest big money in setting up dolphin watching boats... they get thousands of divers a weekend already and the facilities are still poor.
Well - I know it's worked already in some places as I've actually seen it on NHK.

A quick Google looking for that though brought up this......
Tokyo Weekender - Tourism in Japan - 10 fun things to do - Visit Japan Campaign - Yokoso Plan

10 fun things to do in Japan - have a look at number 10! :eyebrow:

It seems that someone in Futo is getting the message after all. After Futo there is only Taiji left.

By the way - as support for my contention that it's the LIVE animal trade that's driving this this link has some information about the sad realities of THAT business.
BlueVoice.org - Saving Dolphins and Whales, Protecting the Oceans
 
10 fun things to do in Japan - have a look at number 10! :eyebrow:

It's also got "working on a farm" and canyoning in there :-)

I think Okinawa is 100x better as a dolphin watching destination in Japan, plus it gets a lot of tourists all year round currently.
 
For any MIXI (japanese version of facebook/myspace) users out there, I found a 'save the dolphin' community

Mixi Iruka tasukete community (link will only work for mixi members)

This is good as it is shows a growing interest and awareness among the Japanese. If you have any japanese friends, let them know about this mixi community.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top Bottom