We just returned from a 1 week stay at Beaches after hurricane Irene. We did 3 days of 2-tank diving. 3 dives at Northwest Point and 3 dives in Grace Bay. The visibility at Northwest Point is absolutely terrible right now - probably less than 15 feet. Usually it is in excess of 80 feet. However, despite this, we did have some cool close encounters with sharks on every dive. I didn't see many lion fish at all. There was someone on our dives who was capturing lion fish on every dive. He is actually studying them as part of his university studies - so this is not a permanent thing. Grace Bay dive sites - the visibility was better but still limited to 25 feet or so. Again, we were pleasantly surprised to have several close shark encounters. There were also a number of large schools of fish. If the visibility had been better, I'm sure we would have seen even more.
As "dive snobs" who are used to diving the "better" sites off the south of Provo, like West Caicos, French Cay and the Sandborne Channel, we were pleasantly surprised. Unfortunately, the coral itself is now covered in sediment from the storm. Hopefully it won't damage the reef. The water temperature was cooler than usual - again a result of the storm. We had opted to not bring wetsuits and use theirs if needed because our luggage was already full and heavy as we were travelling with our 2 young children. I really noticed the thermoclines but then the thrill of seeing a shark would warm my body up again! We didn't need wetsuits, however if we had done another day, I think it would have been the time to do it.
As a side note, we had also done 2 days of diving in Grand Turk before going to Beaches. Visibility was much better in Grand Turk, but still not what it should be. I plan to post a full trip report soon.
I found the whole experience of diving with the in-resort dive operation at Beaches to be mixed. It really depended on who your assigned DM was. One day our DM was super strict and was giving us grief for not being close enough together as a buddy pair. We could see each other - so we were within 10 feet of each other, constantly checking, so that was a little annoying. Most of the DMs were extremely strict about being back on the boat within 45 minutes for the first dive and 30 minutes for the second dive. I thought this was a little extreme. The second dive could easily be at least 45 minutes as well. On the last day, we had a much more flexible DM. We did our tour and saw that all of us had lots of air left and lots of time, so we were able to stay down for almost 50 minutes. This was great because I often find some of the best critter activity in the shallower areas at the top of the reef.
I'm sure operations were not typical during our trip...everything was impacted by the poor visibility and the fact that the resort was closing down. There were lots of training courses going on at the time as well. I found out when I got home they were offering courses at a 50% discount. As a result, there were 4 DMs on board and each group had 4 - 6 people, separated by cert level.
All in all, I wouldn't pay for diving with this type of organization. It was included in the package price, so I will take what I can get. It is convenient to be able to drop the kids off at X-Box garage and/or Camp Sesame and then just walk down to the beach. We had considered going diving with Flamingo or Caicos Adventures, but decided to just go with what was included. Given the conditions at the moment, I think we made the right call.