This message board doesn't have a lot of reports on AKR, but what there are paint a pretty good picture. I wouldn't worry about the reports being more recent than 6 months- it has maintained its act for many long years. Old reports are still quite valid.
Positives? If you are new divers, they will take pretty good care of you- they see a lot of freshly minted divers in their mix of cruise ship divers- most are attracted by the promise of "Flipper".
It's a good place to take a family with kids, and if you want to hit the lively party scene of the West End- it's just a short cab ride away.
The negatives I see about the place are the 65 steps up and down to the restaurant for every meal, and the water taxi back and forth to your room. Makes it kind of hard to 'dash back to the room' for this or that forgotten pre-dive item. Some rooms are on the main island of Roatan's hillside and they are completely breeze-less, the rest of the resort isn't a whole lot better, but they do have a/c in all units. Wind and wave during Sept>March can be rather difficult what with the "Northers", but this would be similar to any West End or North Side operation.
To counter this, they have a nice fleet of deep-vee ProDive boats. Sometimes they get a bit full.
All in all, for a high-end priced resort on the island of Roatan, it is still a bargain by any Caribbean comparison. Good consistent dive operation, restaurant, accomodations, and general service. kind of unusual for Roatan! Aspendiver's website shows AKR and a different resort on Roatan, FIBR, where most of the above positive descriptors are harder to come by. (Although I prefer the "diving zone" of FIBR, these local zone variations are very well discussed here on SCUBABoard) Newer divers are likely to enjoy AKR's diving more.