Diver Accident Death

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for the good wishes DiverG. After the vitriol expressed here because (like you) I said I would have preferred to hear about this accident, and the knowing comment from somebody that "Opal will talk to me but don't repeat anything," I'm on the fence about continuing to dive.

Personally, I think they would be better off without a customer like you. And since you can't understand respecting the confidentiality of a personal conversation, I'd recommend Opal not speak to you at all about it. You're a trouble maker looking to pick a nit for some reason.
 
I can't imagine the pain the family is in after this tragic accident. Thoughts and prayers go out to the family. Sounds like the dive OP did the best possible job trying to resuscitate the diver and provide privacy for his family.
I can understand the shock and sadness that NLB must have felt as he is reading his morning fix of Scubaboard and comes across the dive accident thread further compounded by reading later it was with the dive shop he was diving with. Thats the internet for you. Everyone processes tragedy differently. He is entitled to feel the way he does. The dive shop was entitled to handle the accident the best way they felt they could.
I can't recall in any other dive accident thread that the name of the dive op was ever mentioned (I could be wrong)and I often wondered why. This thread answers that question for me. It might be a better policy not to publish that information for the sake of the family's involved and the dive op.
 
Judy, thanks for your thoughtful and balanced comment. Reefhound, the question in my mind is how do you or firstdive2005 know what the contents of my conversation with Opal would be? That scares me.
Perhaps Opal would want me to share whatever it is she tells me. Frankly, I have trouble imagining what she would tell me that would be inappropriate to share. That this has been a hard time for everybody and they did the best they could? No problem sharing that, right? That I'm a jerk because I dared to share my concern on the Internet about hearing of the accident through the Internet first? Nobody should feel obliged to be savaged and then compound the hurt by not being able to tell people they were savaged.

I don't think it's so much that I'm a nitpicker as that you are a bully.

In any event, DiverG's comment that I would be better off diving than defending my right to express an opinion on the Internet is good advice.
 
So does that mean you are about to go get wet? :) The only way I am getting wet today is with a rain shower. I was hoping the leg would be healed enough to get another warm up dive in this weekend, but I am not chacning it. Another 8 days of healing is better IMHO.
 
I am glad the dive op's name was mentioned. In this instance it apparently makes not one bit of difference who the dive op or DM was, and I don't think anyone (well maybe one or two people) will make any negative judgments about Scuba Mau due to this situation, but when the name is withheld of a dive op whose client dies or is injured, it makes me just a bit uneasy. The last time I was aware of something like this, and the incident details and dive op name were deemed "private," I found the name elsewhere and now, each time I hear that dive op mentioned, I wonder just a bit... Enough so that I might not use them if I were otherwise so inclined.

Yes, some op might have some small discomfort for a little while after it is known that one of their clients died, but that is how an unsafe operation, procedure or employee might come to light over time and thereby save someone (that is unless your faith in government regulation is far greater than mine).

Basically, and simply IMHO, the value to divers from public disclosure of dive incidents, including the names of the dive ops, outweighs the value to dive ops of secrecy.
 


A ScubaBoard Staff Message...

Thread closed at request of original poster.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top Bottom