Equipment Dive Knife in an emergency

This Thread Prefix is for incidents caused by equipment failures including personal dive gear, compressors, analyzers, or odd things like a ladder.

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

If you really need shears you need them, but be aware they can create an emergency when you’re trying to solve a problem.
I didn’t get it, can you please explain?
 
I didn’t get it, can you please explain?
A fishing line gets caught on your first stage behind your head. Reach behind with your shears, cut. And you’ve chopped your reg hose. 30s later you’re still entangled and out of gas.

Ed: A reg hose is too fat to be cut by a line cutter. A knife works too slow
 
A fishing line gets caught on your first stage behind your head. Reach behind with your shears, cut. And you’ve chopped your reg hose. 30s later you’re still entangled and out of gas.
Who blindly cuts into their life support gear with shears?

That's like saying you should never use a drill because you might put a hole in your hand.

If you've only got a knife and you've got an entanglement behind your head and you're wildly slashing with it behind your head you could cut your hoses just as easily.
 
Line cutter on my wrist and a knife attached to my BCD. All my daughters use same setup. We mostly dive together so everyone knows where equipment is located if ever needed.
 
Where I dive in cold water there's fish line and mono all over the place. Entanglement is a common issue.

The key is multiple cutting devices in multiple places because you never know what appendage(s) may be bound up. I carry one knife and EMT shears in a BC pocket. A trilobyte on a BC strap and a second one on my console hose. And a second knife and a wire cutter in my drysuit leg pocket on the opposite side of the BC pocket.

Adding I am not a fan of strap on knife mounts as they just become another place to snag things, I like to streamline as much as possible.
 
Ok, this thread has convinced me it's a good idea to add at least one cutting implement. Sounds like between line cutter and shears that the shears are probably the most practical. As long as they are stainless hopefully they last...
 
  • Like
Reactions: DCN
I typically carry a line cutter strapped to my wrist computer, a knife on my waist, and EMT shears in my pocket. I have used both the line cutter and shears to cut fishing line. Both worked, but I found the EMT shears were easier to use, since I didn't need to loop and tension the line. Never actually used the knife underwater.
 
Ok, this thread has convinced me it's a good idea to add at least one cutting implement. Sounds like between line cutter and shears that the shears are probably the most practical. As long as they are stainless hopefully they last...
Most shears will rust after a while, but slowly. The rivet will go first then at the joint with the plastic handle. They will stay sharp for years. But you can get a 3-pack for $8 on Amazon so just replace them every couple of years.
 
Either place your cutting tool where it can be reached with either hand, or have two tools, one for each hand. A single tool on your (for example) left BDC pocket flap is probably useless if your left hand is entangled.
 
Either place your cutting tool where it can be reached with either hand, or have two tools, one for each hand. A single tool on your (for example) left BDC pocket flap is probably useless if your left hand is entangled.

small knife with serrated edge on left pocket of BC; trilobyte on right side of BCD waist strap. Haven't had to use them yet, but they're there.
 

Back
Top Bottom