D4 vs Geo 2 vs Nitek Trio

[richter]

Hi All

I wish to know which of this 3 computers is the most conservative and Liberal. Reason being I have read up some lately and am confused.

I read h t t p://w w w.advanceddivermagazine.com/video/diveriteq.html", it suggests that Geo 2 and Nitek are the most liberal and Suunto most conservative.

When I read h t t p ://w w w.scubaboard.com/forums/computers-gauges-watches-analyzers/326143-two-gas-vs-three-gas-computer-2.html", someone suggests that Nitek is the most conservative compare to the DC his peers are using. I have no idea where his stays and what DC his peers are using. My peers are using Suunto. I just do not wish to use a more conservative computer than them. I rather they sound the alarm to ascent then me doing so.

I am looking more into Nitek as it comes with a digital compass and it is cheaper than a geo 2 as there is a promo now.

I am staying in sg and didn't hear anyone talking about a Nitek.

Please advise.

 

[richter]

Sorry, the system does not allow me to post URL until 5 post I have submitted. I guess is to prevent spamming by advertisers.

 

[CT Sean]

Geo 2 is going to be the most liberal, when using the DSAT algorithm. Suunto's are on the more conservative side but I can't tell you where the Nitek is, though Google seems to indicate that Buhlmann (Nitek) is a bit of a middle ground between DSAT and RGBM

 

[FWADIVER]

geo 2 has choice between dsat and z+ which is buhlmann. dsat is probably the most liberal but the difference between than and the buhlmann is mostly at shallower depths.

 

[richter]

Hi all

Any difference in terms of multidive during the day?

 

[CT Sean]

If you mean will the computers give different NDL times as a result of multiple dives a day then the answer is yes. Based on reading online (including a DPC comparison from scubadiving magazine that I can't find anymore) the subsequent dives are where the differences in algorithms really show up.

**edit** found the scubadiving.com comparison: http://www.scubadiving.com/files/old/images/pdf/200806_chambertest.pdf

you might want to read this as well, the last discussion on D4 vs Geo: http://www.scubaboard.com/forums/co...rs/360947-suunto-d4-vs-oceanic-geo-2-0-a.html

 

[richter]

Thanx for the info sean. I think you have given me what I need.