Cramp question

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

If all fails, then only kneel on one knee.:)
all4, although said with a smiley, your response goes directly to XPATMANX’s question.

When starting scuba classes I suggest students consider a three-point position: kneeling on one knee (with the associated foot touching behind) and the other foot forward on the bottom. It’s also a stable position.
 
To take a stab at answering the question asked a few posts back about the speed of repletion of potassium:

Potassium distributes through the entire body water fairly readily. Body water comprises approximately 70 percent of an adult human. Therefore, the standard "70 kg man" has about 49 kilos of water, or 49 liters (call it 50). Normal potassium levels are between 4 and 5 meq/dl, and nobody's going to be symptomatic above about 3, so let's say the cramping person is down 1 meq/dl. That's a total body deficit of 500 meq. There are about 400 mg of potassium in a banana, or roughly 10 meq. Therefore, you'd have to eat 50 bananas to replete total body potassium deficit.

You could argue that simply pushing the potassium levels in the blood up would do it, which would require less, only about ten bananas. Except the cramping is occurring at the muscle cell level, which is intracellular potassium, so you have to get the mineral out of the eaten banana, into the blood and then into the cells. Potassium transport is not by simple diffusion, so it's not entirely gradient-driven, and requires the proper milieu (pH, glucose, etc.) to occur.

So what I'm trying to say is that a) potassium deficiency is rarely, if ever, a cause of cramping muscles, and b) eating a banana if you're having cramps is not going to make them go away.

Muscle cramping can be a symptom of significantly abnormal mineral levels (eg. calcium) but again, this does NOT occur in people who healthy and are not experiencing unusual fluid losses.
 
Thank you very much, TSandM, for your extremely precise and conscise answer. It affirms essentially what I've been telling my students and trainees for many years. (I'm a science teacher, swimming instructor, and lifeguard trainer.) We've watched atheletes for years forcing down bananas during halftime after experiencing cramps in the first half, all in the hopes of alleviating them for the second half. Kids would ask me what I thought, and I'd tell them, "Keep eating. You should be better by the start of the game NEXT week!" Now I have the numbers to show the coaches!
 
Best way to stop leg cramps while diving? Get a DPV..... :D

Either that or split fins.... :rofl3:

sorry couldn't resist
 
Hey thanks for all the answers guys... I asked my health teacher today about what he thinks could possibly reduce my cramps. He said that dehidration is probably the biggest cause of cramps. He also said that caffeine/ alchohol will have a large effect on hoe hydrated. So if any of you are heavy drinkers, or coffe/ coke people take a break from the fluid. Im trying this to see what the results are. I drink way too much coke.
 
Strange... coke is supposed to contain a lot of potassium ! That's one thing they recommend when you have diarhea...
 

Back
Top Bottom