Dogbowl, I know the feeling. Last March we had a sorry experience with a reputable dive operator. The whole thing felt just like cow herding.
The DMs did not establish a relationship with us. No chit chat, no attempt to figure out what we were interested in. The rental equipment was in poor condition (we have purchased our own equipment since then partly because of that).
We also missed a dive because of a scheduling error on their part.
So we went back diving to the A.I. next door where we had stayed in November, where we knew several of the dive operator’s staff, and where we felt welcome and almost part of the family. The human aspect made it a much more enjoyable and memorable experience. So we’re going back there for another week in August.
I would like to draw an analogy with another leisure activity I’m very familiar with. During the winter, my girlfriend and I are volunteer ski patrollers during the week-ends at a resort an hour south of Montreal. The resort offers very affordable rates. On a given Saturday, we often have 5000 skiers on the slopes. Ski lift lines are crowded, it’s hard to feel zen at times. At the beginning of the season on opening weekend, we often only have one open run. We call it the WROD (White Ribbon of Death) because skiers of all levels, from beginner kids to unruly teenagers racing by are all on the same run.
Another thought I would like to share with you. From a canadian perspective, with our weak currency, Mexico offers the best bang for the buck for a vacation. The only other great value vacation in my opinion would be a trip to the american southwest landing in Las Vegas and then taking a rental car to the grand canyon, Bryce and Zion. But I digress.
As a comparison, we thought about driving a few hours south to beautiful Boston for the week-end, but hotel rates were 500-800 usd per night anywhere near downtown, not including food or parking. So two days in Boston this week-end would have cost us the same price as an entire week at our favorite all inclusive Resort in Cozumel, including hotel, airfare and food. I guess unless prices rise sharply in the future in Cozumel, we are bound to see additional hordes of tourists invade the island.