Cousteau

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Gidds

Contributor
Messages
5,558
Reaction score
2
Location
Witness Protection Program (hiding from the MOFia)
I am watching the Cousteau Odyssey DVDs.

If the Captain were alive today would you dare critique him on his technique i.e. "hand diving", finning, and wearing the red touque to penetrate the Britanic?
 
Since they did most of their dives sans a BC bladder I'm reserving judgement until I try a backpack next summer.

As for the touque, as long as it's worn over the mask strap what the heck, it'll just slip off if fouled.

Now all of that smoking was just plain foolish.

Pete
 
Actually I don't think he's been on film with the cigarette but I have a book of his that I just got and I think it's hanging off his lip in one of the photos. The hat was worn as one would wear a hood.
 
Read "the Silent World" from Cousteau and after that, try to criticise. Damn, they invented the sport. It's like criticising the Wright brothers for not using GPS on their first flights. This said without any bad feelings, the question is relevant Gidds.
 
I thought up the question after thinking about the tone of some of the posts around here ;) and discussing it with my buddy who lent me the DVDs.
 
The red touque on the 370 ft Brittanic dive was a bit much, especially since all the other divers were wearing hoods. It struck me as a want-to-make-sure-everyone-knows-it's-me gesture.

I was not overly impressed with their penetration techniques either.

From what I have heard and seen Cousteau was not exactly progressive in some areas. For example none of his divers use BC's but horse collar and back inflate BC's were around and in common use at the time. So personally, there is not much excuse for the hand diving and bottom bouncing done in many of the DVD's. But then again, the behavior was considered normal for the time. We had a similar discussion several months back about his archeological techniques and ethics. They do not meet today's much higher standards, but were acceptable at that time.

One of the strongest critisims I heard was regarding some of his cave diving exploits where JMC inisisted on using flares rather than electric lights and in the process contaminated some otherwise pristine cave systems with the chemical residue from the numerous flares used. They look cool, I guess that's what counted.

Jean-Michelle Cousteau spoke at one of our college scuba club meetings in the early 80's. He was very environmentally focused and his view of equipment was very advanced and very visionary. At that time he was using what looked a lot like a US Divers UDS system but with 4500 psi tanks. He impressed me a great deal - much more so than his father.
 
I was thinking he just forgot to take the hat off since he geared up on camera. I had a good laugh when I realized he had it on underwater though.
 
You know, I grew up watching The Undersea World of Jacques Cousteau and his show made me want to become a diver ever since I was a little girl. I think Cousteau Odysessy was his PBS show. I'd love to watch both those series now and be able to see them from the perspective of a fan from a long time ago. I'm sure I would love seeing them again. What I remember about the Odysessy was its emphasis on how the oceans had deteriorated from the time JYC had been diving. I think his ultimate message was always environmental. He was a visionary.
 
It's really awareness. There were so few relative divers in the early days. For all they really knew then it was like walking in a forest right? Doesn't the grass we trample today just grow back in a week or so? What is disguised so eloquently as Exploration is often compared to rape of the environment if not at least highly intrusive and destructive. As our awareness and understanding of the length of time it has taken for species to form, new reefs to grow, old reefs to heal ... we have also "elevated" our understanding of how critical it is to be far more cautious in our techniques and instruction about how to observe with the least amount of intrusion possible. The wealth of knowlege brought to us by the "first" guy to do anything is always like a punctuated leap of understanding. But we are in the end left with human tendency toward habits and repeated behaviors.
 
Ok I just got to the part where he's in a cave on Easter Island and he is most definately holding an electric light NOT a flare. I haven't seen all the episodes yet though so I assume I will be seeing flares?
 

Back
Top Bottom