Cayman Brac or Little Cayman?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

From the descriptions above, it seems that you can't go wrong with either LC or the Brac. Doing 3 dives a day, we didn't find a need for a car on LC. But for those of you that have been to Brac, would you recommend a car?


I'm going to say "No...but",

The "No" is because you asked specifically for those that are doing 3 dives/day by using the PM diveboat. With this schedule, there's not really all that much downtime for island exploration after you return from the PM dive...its pretty much a shower, happy hour cocktail, dinner, maybe a movie or karaoki, then to bed, rinse & repeat the next day.

However, the "...but" is because I've been getting a rental car on each visit for 10+ years, and for what we're interested in, it comes in handy. Part of this is due to a difference in schedule: I'm taking it easy and not doing the afternoon dive (besides, my wife is a non-diver and expects me to spend some time with her). As such, we'll go out exploring, having meals out, doing grocery shopping, make social visits, shore snorkeling, tidepools, parrot reserve orchid trail, etc. It also used to be that one could get free tanks and go shore diving, but with Divi shutting down and Reef Divers charging for tanks, its not really an inexpensive option like it used to be.

FYI, a decent number of visitors will make arrangements for either a car or motor scooters for their last day on island ... something to do for that 24 SI before the flight home ... and do a one day whirlwind island tour. While this does help visitors start to explore the Brac, because you're trying to cram it all into a single day, you're unlikely to slow down and spend an hour with Tenson Scott and hear the story of the Dirty Joke Necklace, or some of the old, old, old history of the Brac...or even some of the more recent news.

For example, up until probably 1960, a common business enterprise was for Braccer men to sail a few hundred miles south to the "Serrenna" keys. They would harvest wild seabird eggs and take them to market in Jamacia, then sail back to Cayman with the cash and other purchased supplies, just to repeat the cycle through the nesting season.

On my most recent visit to Tenson at NIM Things, he pulled out some old photos. They had been taken on one such "egging" expedition from 1937. I didn't have my good camera with me, so here's my (poor resolution) copies:

Every white dot is a nesting bird:
mip.jpg


Palatial living quarters:
mip.jpg


Lighthouse, probably lit by kerosene:
mip.jpg


I've not been able to find this "Serrenna Key" location on a map yet. I do know that there's a shallow bank 200 miles due south, which I believe is the likely location, and this may also be the same location as mentioned in a shipwreck survival story that's documented in the Hurricane of '32 book. I don't think its Swan Island (17.410556 N,83.921944 W), as I believe that that location is too far to the west (and too rocky), although I do know that historically, the Caymans have had family ties with both Honduras and Cuba. As such, its still on my "to be researched" historical mystery list, so any insight is appreciated.

In any event, if you do choose to get a car, there's a couple of companies (DDDD's, B&H, CB), and what they all have in common is that they're locally owned...the Avis and Hertz franchises went out of business long ago. We've been using DDDD's (Four D's) for years and their rate is just above $200/week, plus gas. Call ahead to 345.948.1599 and they'll meet you at the airport, which saves you the cost of hotel transfers.


-hh
 
IMO, a great dive site on LC is Blacktip Blvd a/k/a Land of the Giants ... no black tip sharks, but the "a/k/a Land of the Giants" was appropriately named for the many giant barrel sponges on the dive site ..


Ah, another "alias" dive site name to record in my trivia. Can you recall who mentioned this alternative name? Ie, was it the staff of a particular dive operation?


-hh
 
HH qoute: "In the Jackson's Bight section, it initially starts at only 40-50fsw for the wall's main dropoff, but its also deeper to the sand on the inside...60 to 120...plus the wall's edge gets progressively deeper as you run west, with Cascades being quite deep (100ft)."

Actually HH, it is the other way around. Cascades is on the east end of the Bloody Bay Marine Park. Yes, the wall starts at around 100 feet. The highest point at Cascades starts at 52 feet. But it is a cool dive to see the way the sand "cascades" down to the wall. You can really see that when you get to the wall and look back to shore. You are correct that it is the least dived of the sites in the marinie park, and for the reasons you mention, most exposed, deep, current, etc. (I think you fixed that in your later comments.)

We also push to visit the non "must see" sites. We have had some good fortune in that regard. McCoy's, Bush Gardens, and Jigsaw to name a few. Even some of the spur and groove formation on the south side. Jigsaw generally does have a current though.

Both islands are great places to visit.

A big plus for the Brac is the restaurants, you can visit Aunt Sha's, if it is still open, although moved, La Esparanza for the jerk chicken and ribs, and some of the others. Supplies are much easier to get there as well.
 
HI I lived in the Cayman islands for 5 years, I think if your looking for something fun with a bit of activitie with other people around, Brac is perfect. Also most dive operators there will include a trip to Little in their package. If your looking for eat sleep dive, quite, Little is the only answer. Both are fantastic and you wont be dissapointed. Would suggest for these islands a hotel like Brac Reef. Grand Cayman is always top pick for Condos. Love it!!!
 
Ah, another "alias" dive site name to record in my trivia. Can you recall who mentioned this alternative name? Ie, was it the staff of a particular dive operation?


-hh

Reef Divers ... Phil, staff member.
 
HH qoute: "In the Jackson's Bight section, it initially starts at only 40-50fsw for the wall's main dropoff, but its also deeper to the sand on the inside...60 to 120...plus the wall's edge gets progressively deeper as you run west, with Cascades being quite deep (100ft)."

Actually HH, it is the other way around. Cascades is on the east end of the Bloody Bay Marine Park.

Whoops!

You know, the most embarassing part of that mistake is that there's a 3' x 4' map of Little Cayman hanging on the wall in my home office, right next to my PC.

Yes, the wall starts at around 100 feet. The highest point at Cascades starts at 52 feet. But it is a cool dive to see the way the sand "cascades" down to the wall. You can really see that when you get to the wall and look back to shore. You are correct that it is the least dived of the sites in the marinie park, and for the reasons you mention, most exposed, deep, current, etc. (I think you fixed that in your later comments.)

I found the depth trace (data file) for Cascades over the weekend, but got distracted. I'll try to remember to post it later tonight.

We also push to visit the non "must see" sites. We have had some good fortune in that regard. McCoy's, Bush Gardens, and Jigsaw to name a few. Even some of the spur and groove formation on the south side. Jigsaw generally does have a current though.

I've heard of Jigsaw; haven't been there. On the south side, I enjoyed Grundy's Gardens (shallow) - - of course, the last time that I had dived it, my buddy was the LCBR's first cook (Steve...he's since moved on).

A big plus for the Brac is the restaurants, you can visit Aunt Sha's, if it is still open, although moved, La Esparanza for the jerk chicken and ribs, and some of the others. Supplies are much easier to get there as well.

With Coral Isle being damaged in '04 by Ivan, Aunt Sha had relocated to a small house on the North side, not too far east of Tibbets Square. Here's one news article and here's a second one.

Unfortunately, something has happened to Sharon Connolly ("Aunt Sha") and I was just told (literally, this past week) that there's some sort of medical - hospital fund being collected...sounds like she's been sick, or something. I've not been able to learn anything more about it online.

In other related news, Coral Isle just re-opened last week, but it appears that for the time being, its going to be 99.9% bar - - no restaurant service (just "bar finger food"). They've reportedly reinforced & raised the seawall that didn't withstand Ivan in 2004.

FYI, here's a photo of Coral Isle (the old Aunt Sha's location) during the flooding from Ivan in 2004; was originally on CaymanNetNews IIRC:

9-15-04%20auntshas.bmp


For point of reference, here's what was left of the docks at the resorts in 2004, after Ivan: Divi and BRBR.


-hh
 
If you really want solitude, lazy days, eat, sleep, dive and some easy conversation at a tiki bar, Little is the spot.- Little Cayman Beach Resort or if your looking for a condo, Conch Club
I don't think you would be dissapointed with either honestly. Little will be a bit more money and again most dive operators include a trip to little from Brac if you decide on Brac.
regards
Margo
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom