JBFG
Contributor
USPS is definitely my favorite.
What sucks is when the shop charges a ridiculous handling price
What sucks is when the shop charges a ridiculous handling price
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
Like any other equipment-intensive sport, scuba diving requires time and experience to learn all the options you have have available. You also will make a lot of tradeoffs based on what you prioritize. If you want your LDS to love you, give them all your money and take what they recommend to you. But that is... not especially sensible. You'll end up with kit based on THEIR priorities. That could be good and it could be bad. Asking around here, you'll get advice based on what the poster prioritizes. I think you understand that. The only hard and fast rule is to make your choices with your eyes wide open, which you are now doing.
As you have surmised, Halcyon gear is premium and commands a premium price. But every reputable gear manufacturer is going to have safe gear. You are not buying safety by spending more money on used gear. For $2500 an experienced diver could buy every piece of kit they needed - including a drysuit. Or they could buy just a one reg set and an overpriced bcd. Or a single dive computer. It depends on what you value in your gear.
The generic advice assumes that your diving live revolves around your dive shop and you want to get everything from them. That is expensive but generally viable. If you like them then you do want to give them business, but it doesn't have to be everything you buy. The regs are the most important and most in need of regular service, so if you buy one piece of gear from your LDS it should be the regs. If you want reg recommendations you need to state what sort of diving you will be doing and what brands your dive shop sells. I'll run through a few items to show you some options.
My pick: Deep6 reg set, about $650. LDS options will cost more, may be prettier, and will have local servicing - but won't perform any better.
BP/W is heavily favored in this community, and I think it gives the best performance in the water at the cost of being a bit more unwieldy to transport. It's a good trade, though, and if your really want to make it easier to travel with you could get a soft backplate. Modular systems have a lot of advantages. I love my DSS rig, but they are out of business atm. I don't think there is any need to spend more than $500 on the full wing, plate, STA, and harness set.
$500 (950 running total)
Dive computers, well, what kind you get really doesn't matter much. I suggest your first dive computer should be whatever has the best sale price and appeals to you. Just get something. Most divers here regard a Shearwater as the best dive computer, but at $950 for the Perdix AI you don't need one yet. And you'll want a backup dc eventually. So just get a cheap one now on sale, and if you eventually want to upgrade it'll become your backup.
$200 (1150 running total)
Thermal protection is intensely personal, but cold water points towards a drysuit. You can order a bare-bones Seaskin drysuit from the UK for about $600. But honestly, if you are spending that much money on a new custom fit drysuit you might as well add a few of the normal bells and whistles, so it'll be more like $750. Then you need warm undergarments to layer under it. If you have great kit from a hiking or hunting hobby you may not need much, or you might need everything. Call it another $200.
$950 (2100 running total)
Accessories:
Compass $40 DGX
Wrist slate $10
Primary Light: $60 DGX
Backup light: $40 DGX
#24 cave line and half a dozen bolt snaps to secure gear: $30
Total: $2280 usd (not sure what the exchange rate is atm) (doesn't include taxes and brokerage fees)
What more do you need? Well, steel tanks, maybe a better mask or fins if you don't like what you have now. You'll need a pony and its reg set for diving deep in cold water eventually. An smb for boat diving, and flag and float for shore diving. A 5mm or 3mm wetsuit for warmer temps where the drysuit is overkill. But if I had your budget that's where I would start. And I'd have all nice, new, long-term gear.
Also, check out the market for used gear whenever you decide what you want. I got a semidry for less than the cost of a new wetsuit by finding a used deal on ebay. Classifieds here are safer than Ebay, more or less.
You may want to stick with what your LDS has, or some mix of LDS, used, and online. Whatever works best for you. Just keep your eyes open.
@Gee.Eleven
I had a hunch you were in the DDS area when you said your LDS was selling their BP/W rental gear
Not many dive shops teach OW student with that gear.
This is it. ScubaSwap.org - Home@Gee.Eleven
There’s a group in Ontario that has a swap meet every April, I believe. @racanichou can give you more details. Might be worth the drive.