99% of my recreational dive travel I would show my AI card, most of the time I was given a wide berth and allowed to do as a please because of it. Sometimes I was buddied with the inexperienced diver or a diver with physical limitations. But because it was a recreational dive anyway I never really cared and can tell you some of my most rewarding dives were with those buddies mentioned. Mainly because I took the time to dive to their limits. Really funny time was when I ended up leading the second dive on a trip in Hawaii while the DM/Instructor taught a course. Again, I didn't care, kept the group together, had fun.
One occasion, I had to actually do a rescue on the first dive with my buddy that was physically handicapped, dive was way beyond his limits, but on the second dive we had a great time, kept him shallow and we had a longer BT than most of the boat!
Now that I let my AI card expire, I leave it and my DM card at home and only carry my full mix card. But it has been years now since I have actually done a tourist dive on a cattle boat.