Thanks again for the recent replies! Yes, we are going to Bonaire. We would like to give Curacao a try at some point too, but Bonaire is calling us! Good advice with regard to the booties.
I have slip on fins that don't require booties. I don't even think they will go over booties. Any other suggestions/ways to not kill my feet????
Thanks for the suggestions on using the house reefs at the various hotels. I think we will keep that in mind when/if we venture out on our own. We are going to stick with the dive guide at first and see where that takes us. Maybe we will be confident without a guide after a few days, we'll see.
Still leaning toward using Bas Noij. He seems like an amazing DM from what I have read here and on Bonaire Talk! However, the owners of the cottage we plan to rent have suggested Tropical Divers too. It's harder to find reviews for them. Found a few and they were good.
So many things to consider.
I hope to be able to help others on this board after I get back and get some experience/insights.
Thanks so much everyone!
Waterproof/rubber sandals! The ones with tire tread soles work great
Wear the sandles on entry and exit, carrying the fins in your hands, till you are @ waste deep. Then don the fins, and stow the sandals on a bcd strap or weight belt. Worked very well for my brother and his kids last year on Bonaire ( simply forgot to suggest boots and strap fins when we planned the trip, my fault).
Entries while wearing fins is asking for trouble, and bare foot, even on hard pan coral can be painful.