I'll get my log book out tonight and fill in the names of the dive sites.
The diving in the Bahamas really does NOT compare to Cozumel. In 17 dives in the Bahamas, we saw ONE anemone. A handful of small grouper, no trunkfish, a few coronet fish, and a couple of turtles.
You can see all of that in one dive in Cozumel. All week I looked for Flamingo Tongues and finally found one. Last time I was in Cozumel, I counted 17 on a single dive.
I'm not saying you didn't have a good time on your trip. That's separate. I had a good time on Blackbeard's too but the diving was nowhere near as good as Cozumel, Belize or the West end of Roatan.
-Charles