From my experience,in Cozumel since 1992, the following hurricanes have had a impact of some sort.
Surely there were strong hurricanes to hit Cozumel before Gilbert but then it was not a tourist destination until the 70s.
Gilbert of course in 1988, that was the historical "big one".
Roxanne in October 1995 Lots of damage, 135 mph winds the eye right downtown but went thru fast.
Mitch November 1998, glancing blow but hurt nonetheless
Ivan 2004 also glancing blow but still hurt.
Emily July 2005 eye hit Punta Sur but went through quickly and damage downtown was limited. Southern hotels were closed for a long time and many had not recovered by the time Wilma came along.
Wilma October 2005 Not the strongest hurricane to hit Cozumel, Gilbert was at higher velocity when it hit, but Wilma hung around way past her welcome. Maybe more destructive because there is much more to hurt now.
Dave Dillehay
Aldora Divers