A +10 diopter should focus at 10cm or 4" inches from the back of the glass and allow you to use full zoom, meaning 3" from the front
So the comparison is camera at full wide at 1cm or at full zoom at 10cm. Usually at 1cm you have no space to lit the subject so the second option is best
However if your camera has little zoom less than 85mm equivalent the magnification is none to little. You need then a stronger diopter to get even closer
Ultimately on a compact it depends on the amount of zoom available and the size of the captured frame
So the comparison is camera at full wide at 1cm or at full zoom at 10cm. Usually at 1cm you have no space to lit the subject so the second option is best
However if your camera has little zoom less than 85mm equivalent the magnification is none to little. You need then a stronger diopter to get even closer
Ultimately on a compact it depends on the amount of zoom available and the size of the captured frame