Question Air consumption, is mine good?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Awkwatic

Registered
Messages
25
Reaction score
27
Location
SE Wisconsin
# of dives
0 - 24
First, I am a brand new diver. I did my first non cert dive in open water yesterday. I'm a big dude, 310lbs 6'3", diving cold water OC. Wetsuit.

I went with a Steel HP120 yesterday, and kept track of my psi and bottom time and average depth. Bottom time was 56mins, average depth was 15ft, beginning pressure was 3500 or tad below. Ended my dive with 800psi.


My insta-buddy remarked after the dive that I have insanely efficient air consumption to stay down that long on a single tank and still have 800 ending the dive. I threw my numbers into the SAC calculator and came up with
You consumed 92.1 cubic feet of air.
Your SAC rate is 32.4 PSI per minute.
Your RMV rate is 1.131 cubic feet per minute.

I just don't know what those numbers specifically mean. Did my calculations get screwed up? Or are those numbers good?
 
15ft is pretty shallow.

Don’t worry about your SCR. Just go have fun and your consumption will improve over time.

I’m suspicious of any male diver who boasts about his ultra low consumption. Anybody can float, wiggle a fin every ten minutes and pretend to have sippy cup lungs.

When we actually fin in a sustained manner, like actually going for a hike, and still have an average to great SCR - then I’m listening.

OTOH, female divers are the real deal; they’re blessed with divine physiology. While the rest of us are looking to end the dive around 50bar, they still have 90-100bar left.
 
First, I am a brand new diver. I did my first non cert dive in open water yesterday. I'm a big dude, 310lbs 6'3", diving cold water OC. Wetsuit.

I just don't know what those numbers specifically mean. Did my calculations get screwed up? Or are those numbers good?

I'm like you similar weight about 6'1

Fifteen feet is basically safety stop level are you sure you wrote the correct aveerage depth?

In cold water for me that's 22c 72F I use an AL 80 and with your average depth would do a 90 minute dive if my dive buddy could stand the cold. Being fat means self insulated I dive in Tshirt and shorts.

For a new diver yes decent but high gas consumption but we don't know what currents you did or did not have or if you had to exert yourself on the dive. I don't go diving to exert myself as if on a trail hill climbing I dive as slow as possible and to spot some really nice critters you want to have no movement at all.

Yet last month in Maldives I did 47 dives often with Tiger sharks and other sharks and many were in strong currents so my RMV was a little higher.

Average Gas Consumption My RMV is quite low in what I would say near perfect conditions where I am not diving against currents. Usually at the .3 cubic feet per minute.

This dive average depth 20.2m or 66 feet for an hours dive.


20.2m AVERAGE.jpg
 
I think I dove with you yesterday at Pearl. Your RMV is high at 1.1. That takes in an average depth of 15ft, but I'd suggest it was a bit deeper. I'd be happy to dive with you again. Also, for some reason it was a sprint to see how far to go. If I'm wrong about your identity, feel free to correct me :)

Edited to add, I got a 24.3ft avg depth, assuming we're talking the same dive
 
First, I am a brand new diver. I did my first non cert dive in open water yesterday. I'm a big dude, 310lbs 6'3", diving cold water OC. Wetsuit.

I went with a Steel HP120 yesterday, and kept track of my psi and bottom time and average depth. Bottom time was 56mins, average depth was 15ft, beginning pressure was 3500 or tad below. Ended my dive with 800psi.


My insta-buddy remarked after the dive that I have insanely efficient air consumption to stay down that long on a single tank and still have 800 ending the dive. I threw my numbers into the SAC calculator and came up with
You consumed 92.1 cubic feet of air.
Your SAC rate is 32.4 PSI per minute.
Your RMV rate is 1.131 cubic feet per minute.

I just don't know what those numbers specifically mean. Did my calculations get screwed up? Or are those numbers good?
1.13 cu ft per minute at an average depth of 15 feet is not insanely efficient air consumption - it’s actually high. That said, for a new diver it’s normal to have higher air consumption at first but it will generally get significantly better over time as you gain more experience and get more relaxed/comfortable underwater.

My first few OW dives had my RMV at around 1-1.1 cu ft per minute. However, with approximately 350 dives under my belt now, I typically achieve 0.35-0.42 cu ft per minute depending on dive profile/depth (and if I carry a camera or not). Strong currents or excessive swimming will drive it up a bit, but usually still no higher than 0.45 - 0.48 or so.
 
More than 15l or 0.5cu/ft is pretty high, twice that is almost panic breathing.
15l/min what I use pushing a large camera in drysuit with doubles in moderate current.
 
Your RMV is your RMV.
As a newbie diver your consumption will be a bit higher, that's normal.
It will drop to normal values (normal for you) when you get more experience and confidence.

But do not fall for the I have the lowest RMV trap . . . . . . there's no value you should be at.
Everyones lungs are a different size, I've had buddy's that do 11L/min and buddy's that do 18L/min. (all with good experience some even experienced tech divers with consumption close to 18L)
If it's cold, you breathe a bit more, if it's warm you breathe a bit less, if there's a strong current you breathe a bit more, etc.

What you should NOT do, is breathing below comfort level to achieve a low RMV.
 
First, I am a brand new diver. I did my first non cert dive in open water yesterday. I'm a big dude, 310lbs 6'3", diving cold water OC. Wetsuit.

I went with a Steel HP120 yesterday, and kept track of my psi and bottom time and average depth. Bottom time was 56mins, average depth was 15ft, beginning pressure was 3500 or tad below. Ended my dive with 800psi.


My insta-buddy remarked after the dive that I have insanely efficient air consumption to stay down that long on a single tank and still have 800 ending the dive. I threw my numbers into the SAC calculator and came up with
You consumed 92.1 cubic feet of air.
Your SAC rate is 32.4 PSI per minute.
Your RMV rate is 1.131 cubic feet per minute.

I just don't know what those numbers specifically mean. Did my calculations get screwed up? Or are those numbers good?
I had to translate this to metric to make any sense of it. If Google didn't lie to me, 1.13cft per minute translate to 31 litres per minute which is actually a very high RMV. When I started, my RMV was around 20-25 litres per minute though I have the "benefit" of being a short, fat woman. You don't need to worry about your RMV too much right now.

When we begin to dive, our air consumption is fairly high simply because we are new to diving so the excitement and maybe a little anxiety cause us to breathe more rapidly than we do when we are very comfortable. In addition to this, your trim, buoyancy and propulsion techniques won't yet be on point. If your trim is off, i.e., you are not perfectly horizontal and are perfectly streamlined with your equipment, the drag of the water against you will increase your air consumption. If your buoyancy is off and you spend a lot of time inflating and deflating your BCD, you will lose air this way. Your pressure gauge does not differentiate between whether you have breathed the air or whether you used it to inflate your BCD. Your propulsion techniques should be chosen according to circumstances. If you are just calmly diving along a reef without any currents, and there's no need to rush, slow, strong frogkicks will save you some air compared to constant flutter kicks. Flutter kicks can be more appropriate against currents or where speed is required. So perfecting your propulsion technique will absolutely save you some air. The same goes for turning around. If you're doing a basic reef dive, i.e., 20min left-hand shoulder to go, 20min right-hand shoulder to come back, how do you turn around? If you swim in a circle to turn, learn how to helicopter turn. It's quick, easy and on the spot. What do you do if you're diving behind someone and suddenly they stop in mid-air? Do you need to flail your arms, do you need to dive in a little circle around them til they keep moving? Those will cost you air, too. If you learn how to hover, you can conserve air that way. Hovering is also really useful if you need to stay still to look at a fish, a turtle, a coral, etc. And finally, also very important, if you are facing a coral full of clownfish and you're done looking, where do you go to make room for the next diver? Everyone will be trying to get a view of the clownfish, so there's divers to your left, your right and probably above you (maybe even below you...). That's right, you go backwards! Learn how to back kick early on, that way you can avoid chaotically swimming sideways through everyone, trying not to bump into other divers looking at the same clownfish.

These are just tips and thoughts for improving your RMV by addressing factors under your control. Obviously environmental aspects such as currents will play a role but you cannot control the currents, only your response to them. If I were you, I'd keep track of my RMV even as a beginner diver. If you ever get to a point where you plan your dives independently, knowing your RMV in different conditions and depths will be very valuable to your planning.
 
As a newbie myself, just keep diving. Your air consumption will slowly and naturally improve. Just like buoyancy. It just takes time and practice which is awesome, because, who doesn't want to dive more?
Happy diving!
 

Back
Top Bottom