Hmm .. thanks guys. My original trip was going to be Cozumel but its like i keep hearing of boats sinking and divers dying there, not to mention the strong currents that I've been looking at an alternative. Looks like I may need to up the budget. The arguments for staying at a reef resort are compelling and even though Cozumel was much cheaper, I can compensate that by maybe getting 15 to 20 dives in.
Arsalan, There is no doubt there is very good advice in this thread regarding Bonaire. As said, diving Bonaire is wonderful and very suitable for all levels. I believe you and your Newbie buddy will enjoy it very much. My 2 cents worth is similar to what is already mentioned. Rent a truck, get thick sole booties, acquire a copy
Bonaire Shore Diving Made Easy, perhaps hire a private divemaster for your first couple of days and then go and enjoy ! If you stay at a waterfront property, you may want to just stick to the house reef for the first couple of days in order to get familiar to the routine of things. However, if you want to venture out, the southern sites from around the Salt Pier and north to town are usually very easy entry and easy going. Sites north of town do have interesting entries or access, ie: Oil Slick, Thousand Steps and Karpata, however, they too are very doable. Currents are very easy to non-existent overall and the dives can be enjoyed at a slow pace. In fact, my hubby and I often end up staying in the immediate area upon entering between 40 to 60 feet for the entire hour-hour and a half dive. Or, if we decide to venture further we enter at shore, descend and gradually make our way out to the buoy (if there is one). We turn into the current (if there is any) and then proceed until we get to half tank. At which point, we turn around and head back to the point of entry, slowly ascending and including our safety stop as we make it to shore. Should you get off point a bit, no worries. All you need to do is surface, look for your truck then swim to it. You may want to descend to just below water surface to reduce your drag and make the swim a bit easier. However, even if you are at 5 feet remember to surface slowly.
Now, in so much that Bonaire is a fantastic place, I also will mention that ruling out Cozumel because of boats sinking and divers dying is not a reason to not dive there. Boats sink wherever there are boats in the water and tragically fatalities do happen in this sport we enjoy. Boats sink due to mechanical problems as well as water conditions. Divers die due to error, unforeseen dive conditions and natural causes. As far as the strong currents, yes, Cozumel is known to be an area for drift diving, and sometimes you end up flying rather fast, however, many beginner divers enjoy diving there every day. But with proper instruction and experience, drift diving is something that can be mastered. If and once you feel you would like to try Cozumel, go on over to the Cozumel forum and research a bit. Read the reviews and get an idea of how it all works there. I always recommend for new Cozumel divers to read the reviews, choose 3-5 dive ops that interest them and then contact the dive op with questions. This process can take a bit of time as there are many reputable and professional dive ops in Cozumel. Once you have a dive op confirmed, then, find lodging that works well for you and your dive op. Just be forwarned, there is also a
very Active and very Vocal Cozumel Scubaboard community who do, at times, let there passion for Cozumel run amuck in their comments and responses. Sometimes, the discussions can evolve into a sensation of sorts, which, may be why you are leary about diving there. I do know there has been some recent activity regarding a boat sinking . However, considering the hundreds of boats that are used by the dive and fishing industry in Cozumel, a sinking is actually quite uncommon. This also applies to diver fatality. Without a doubt, a tragic event as such does affect the diving community a great deal, however, it is what it is and sadly something that does happen. The best we can do is keep ourselves and our buddies as safe as possible and do whatever we can to dive another day.
Arsalan, no matter where you dive, Best Wishes to you and Happy Diving !!! Do your research, be open to learning about the sport, improving your skills, and enjoy ! And, as my Cozumel Divemaster, Pedro Pablo of Blue XT Sea diving has told me for the past 12 years, "Take is slow".