I don't think anyone is criticizing SSI instructors, only the "authortativeness" of their written materials on what should be a "standard" tech hand signal.
It is fair to point out that SSI is new to the tech space compare to TDI, IANTD, GUE, etc. and therefore the hand signal chart in SSI materials, which seems out of step on this issue, might not be the best reference compared to more established tech-oriented agencies, none of which to my knowledge teach that.
Honestly, using the deco sign in that fashion to elicit info about NDL sounds exactly what a recreational oriented agency would do.
Signals need to be understood and if I'm on a recreational dive, for example, much as I would prefer to hold 2 fingers horizontally to signal 7, I know that most recreational divers won't understand. Speak their language if you want to be understood.
It is fair to point out that SSI is new to the tech space compare to TDI, IANTD, GUE, etc. and therefore the hand signal chart in SSI materials, which seems out of step on this issue, might not be the best reference compared to more established tech-oriented agencies, none of which to my knowledge teach that.
Honestly, using the deco sign in that fashion to elicit info about NDL sounds exactly what a recreational oriented agency would do.
Signals need to be understood and if I'm on a recreational dive, for example, much as I would prefer to hold 2 fingers horizontally to signal 7, I know that most recreational divers won't understand. Speak their language if you want to be understood.