MichaelMc
Working toward Cenotes
TLDR: I collected a list of reg stow mechanisms with short pro/con and links. Comments welcome.
Background: Tbone's thread, A need to rehash our discussion on primary donate, focused on beyond single or double back mount, prompted thinking about the options for frequent reg stow and release with fast OOG response. Sub optimal to primary donate necklace secondary, but sometimes needed. Specifically for double sidemount, where having primary donate with necklace secondary 100% of the dive can conflict with other safety goals in some environments. Double hose and rebreather can have a similar secondary donate issue, though without the need of frequent restow.
This post: I collected this list to see if I'm missing options, and for others future reference. I already use a decent method from it and all of this is already sprinkled throughout the sidemount forum. But collecting it seemed valuable. I grouped them into categories. Ignoring hose routing as much as possible. Just looking at how to get the reg to stay or release when desired.
I didn't post it in basic as I think primary donate necklaced secondary is a great single tank solution, even if not often taught yet. Adding a discussion in basic of "You should primary donate, but how *would* you use/restow/donate a non-necklace secondary if you had to?" seems counter productive. The Z system has threads debating its merits. This thread, or just post, is about options for frequent stow/release of regs with fast OOG response. And I say response, not necessarily just release, as the regs are your backups not just your buddies.
Fast reg release seems prudent in mixed teams or with nearby single tank divers. I think mixed teams, and the need to donate, is common for new sidemount divers, certainly those starting sidemount as rec. divers. I dive two tank OW sidemount, always in mixed teams or solo. It isn't always needed, such as deep in an overhead where everyone has multiple gas sources.
Do people see omissions, needed clarifications, or better pro/con notes?
# Clipped: no error free fast release
Tied with cave line to a bolt-snap and clipped to chest D ring (normal backmount storage on surface)
- pro: simple, little chance to lose
- con: unclip may fumble from cold, haste, or gloves (not a good release ease)
# Clipped: breakaway attachment to bolt-snap
Breakaway cord/o-ring/tiny-ziptie
- pro: can break free in emergency
- con: may break free on own, or degrade in sun
Double ender and bungee 'looped' around reg
- pro: break reg out of bungee & d-ender loop
- con: bit more awkward clip/unclip depending on reg, depends on reg shape
- Variant w/ clamp: Hose retainers. Where and why?
Break out clamp: Plastic 'cloths pin' clamp gripping opposite sides of hose
- pro: clean breakaway, 'standard' bolt snap grip, easy reattachment of breakaway
- con: ?, hose ball swivel may move attach point down hose
- Diving Break Away Connector by Sstteeffaann, Boltsnap breakaways, Hose retainers. Where and why?, SM Exercises
- Some cave line tackeling wrapped on hose prevents it sliding down.
Magnetic break away between bolt-snap and hose Magnetic Hose Clip
- pro: clean breakaway, easy reattachment of breakaway
- con: weak? Hold loose rust from wrecks. Apparently not mess with distant compass.
- There is also a mechanical version with ball and spring leaf loaded socket
# Clipped: slide hose
Sliding bungee constrictor knot on hose, normally by reg, can pull hose through
- pro: will not lose clip, easy mod from cave line version
- con: slow to feed through cinch, can slide down in normal use
- Hemphill: First sidemount dives, Quick version: Hose Clip Retainer
Bungee looped from hose, over mouth piece, to adjustment knob/side
- pro: less risk of accidental breakaway, faster slide than tight cinch
- con: need to pull bungee free, then feed hose through large attached loop
- Similar to Brett Hemphill but w/o the clamp knot
# Tucked
On tank. Hose under bungee loops on tank, like a stage
- pro: clean, free to deploy
- con: longer to restow, may move about and need to find it
Mouthpiece in 'octo' type holder, such as a bungee loop.
- pro: easy to pull free
- con: hard to tuck each time
Reg body under bungee loop on (chest) strap, First sidemount dives
- pro: pull to release, emergency release is same as normal release, no clip
- con: likely only shower head shaped reg
-- (Poseidon Jetstream. Or if reasonably snug Xstream or Oceanic Omega)
- But stretch fabric like DiveRite's Deluxe hose retainers for tanks might allow it with other regs. Hmm.
# Double necklace
Necklace with a left reg, a spacer, a right reg Why not two 7ft hoses when sidemount diving
- pro: donate either from mouth, hose feeds from its own side
- con: hose drag in current/snags
# Hanging free
Let reg dangle down after crossing behind neck
- pro: easy access if it did not move, a quick 'storage' solution
- con: if you roll you may lose it behind you
# Mouth (for completeness)
Loose (ie straight up from that side)
- pro: easy donate, simple hose routing
- con: restrictions can snag and pull free, drag on reg if scootering
Around back of neck
- pro: a snag pulls on neck so not lose reg, supports weight of reg so less jaw effort
- con: need tiny head dip to donate, can only donate topmost behind neck hose
Necklace
- pro: can't go far, depending on knot tightness, right there if lose other reg
- con: must pull free to donate
Gag strap holding reg firmly in mouth
- pro: very hard to lose (such as surf or oxygen convulsions)
- con: slower to swap regs
Background: Tbone's thread, A need to rehash our discussion on primary donate, focused on beyond single or double back mount, prompted thinking about the options for frequent reg stow and release with fast OOG response. Sub optimal to primary donate necklace secondary, but sometimes needed. Specifically for double sidemount, where having primary donate with necklace secondary 100% of the dive can conflict with other safety goals in some environments. Double hose and rebreather can have a similar secondary donate issue, though without the need of frequent restow.
This post: I collected this list to see if I'm missing options, and for others future reference. I already use a decent method from it and all of this is already sprinkled throughout the sidemount forum. But collecting it seemed valuable. I grouped them into categories. Ignoring hose routing as much as possible. Just looking at how to get the reg to stay or release when desired.
I didn't post it in basic as I think primary donate necklaced secondary is a great single tank solution, even if not often taught yet. Adding a discussion in basic of "You should primary donate, but how *would* you use/restow/donate a non-necklace secondary if you had to?" seems counter productive. The Z system has threads debating its merits. This thread, or just post, is about options for frequent stow/release of regs with fast OOG response. And I say response, not necessarily just release, as the regs are your backups not just your buddies.
Fast reg release seems prudent in mixed teams or with nearby single tank divers. I think mixed teams, and the need to donate, is common for new sidemount divers, certainly those starting sidemount as rec. divers. I dive two tank OW sidemount, always in mixed teams or solo. It isn't always needed, such as deep in an overhead where everyone has multiple gas sources.
Do people see omissions, needed clarifications, or better pro/con notes?
# Clipped: no error free fast release
Tied with cave line to a bolt-snap and clipped to chest D ring (normal backmount storage on surface)
- pro: simple, little chance to lose
- con: unclip may fumble from cold, haste, or gloves (not a good release ease)
# Clipped: breakaway attachment to bolt-snap
Breakaway cord/o-ring/tiny-ziptie
- pro: can break free in emergency
- con: may break free on own, or degrade in sun
Double ender and bungee 'looped' around reg
- pro: break reg out of bungee & d-ender loop
- con: bit more awkward clip/unclip depending on reg, depends on reg shape
- Variant w/ clamp: Hose retainers. Where and why?
Break out clamp: Plastic 'cloths pin' clamp gripping opposite sides of hose
- pro: clean breakaway, 'standard' bolt snap grip, easy reattachment of breakaway
- con: ?, hose ball swivel may move attach point down hose
- Diving Break Away Connector by Sstteeffaann, Boltsnap breakaways, Hose retainers. Where and why?, SM Exercises
- Some cave line tackeling wrapped on hose prevents it sliding down.
Magnetic break away between bolt-snap and hose Magnetic Hose Clip
- pro: clean breakaway, easy reattachment of breakaway
- con: weak? Hold loose rust from wrecks. Apparently not mess with distant compass.
- There is also a mechanical version with ball and spring leaf loaded socket
# Clipped: slide hose
Sliding bungee constrictor knot on hose, normally by reg, can pull hose through
- pro: will not lose clip, easy mod from cave line version
- con: slow to feed through cinch, can slide down in normal use
- Hemphill: First sidemount dives, Quick version: Hose Clip Retainer
Bungee looped from hose, over mouth piece, to adjustment knob/side
- pro: less risk of accidental breakaway, faster slide than tight cinch
- con: need to pull bungee free, then feed hose through large attached loop
- Similar to Brett Hemphill but w/o the clamp knot
# Tucked
On tank. Hose under bungee loops on tank, like a stage
- pro: clean, free to deploy
- con: longer to restow, may move about and need to find it
Mouthpiece in 'octo' type holder, such as a bungee loop.
- pro: easy to pull free
- con: hard to tuck each time
Reg body under bungee loop on (chest) strap, First sidemount dives
- pro: pull to release, emergency release is same as normal release, no clip
- con: likely only shower head shaped reg
-- (Poseidon Jetstream. Or if reasonably snug Xstream or Oceanic Omega)
- But stretch fabric like DiveRite's Deluxe hose retainers for tanks might allow it with other regs. Hmm.
# Double necklace
Necklace with a left reg, a spacer, a right reg Why not two 7ft hoses when sidemount diving
- pro: donate either from mouth, hose feeds from its own side
- con: hose drag in current/snags
# Hanging free
Let reg dangle down after crossing behind neck
- pro: easy access if it did not move, a quick 'storage' solution
- con: if you roll you may lose it behind you
# Mouth (for completeness)
Loose (ie straight up from that side)
- pro: easy donate, simple hose routing
- con: restrictions can snag and pull free, drag on reg if scootering
Around back of neck
- pro: a snag pulls on neck so not lose reg, supports weight of reg so less jaw effort
- con: need tiny head dip to donate, can only donate topmost behind neck hose
Necklace
- pro: can't go far, depending on knot tightness, right there if lose other reg
- con: must pull free to donate
Gag strap holding reg firmly in mouth
- pro: very hard to lose (such as surf or oxygen convulsions)
- con: slower to swap regs