Bad dive today, need answers

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

ALaskowski

Registered
Messages
43
Reaction score
0
Location
Bellport, NY Long Island
# of dives
100 - 199
I had a problem with my dive today that forced me to abort and return to the surface and I need to better understand the cause if at all possible. Hope some can give some meaningful input to avoid a repeat.
We were on a boat dive today off of Long Island in the Atlantic for a wreck that laid 60-80’ deep. I have never been prone to seasickness, but there were some decent swells on the way out and I began to feel a bit nauseous. I was probably also a little dehydrated and did not eat breakfast prior (couldn’t find a Duncan Donuts). Anyway, we got to the wreck site and I geared up with the rest of the group. I was diving a 30% blend nitrox on a brand new tank. Those are the pre-incident facts.
Descent down the anchor line went without incident with my buddy right behind me and after noting the limited visibility, I elected to tie a line from my reel to avoid difficulty finding my way back. A few minutes after doing this (approx. 70’), it hit me like a ton of bricks. Now, I have been narced a number of times before and this was very different. I was having difficulty focusing my vision on any particular object and had great difficulty thinking clearly as well as feeling ill – mostly nauseous. Some anxiety was also setting in and my breathing was elevated making me burn through my air.
Impaired as I was, I recognized that this was a dangerous situation and signaled my buddy to team up with one of the other groups next to us and that I was ascending (some may argue sending the buddy off was a bad idea – noted. As stated, I was not thinking clearly). I was making my way back to the anchor line (like 20’ away) and realized I was having extreme difficulty being able to get my hand eye coordination to work to reel up my line and eventually gave up and took it up in a tangled mess to deal with on the surface.
These symptoms largely stayed with me during my ascent and would have been a real problem without an anchor line to assist, as I still couldn’t think clearly and was having problems determining which buttons on my BC inflated and deflated. Nonetheless, I was able to make a controlled ascent and all ended without issue except with not feeling particularly well for a time on the rolling sea.
After leaving the site, I had a good meal which made me feel a lot better and then went home, where fatigue rapidly overcame me and I slept for 2 hours.
My question to you all is what the hell induced that? It strikes me largely as CNS related issues like the first symptoms of oxygen toxicity, but I don’t see how that’s very likely giving my blend had a maximum depth of 120’ and we were at 70 for only a very short time. Or could it be to a culmination of other various stress factors that added up to cause this? I intend to have the tank rechecked as well as verifying the blend to ensure that it was really 30%, but if that all checks out, I need answers…
 
My first thought is bad gas . . . 70 feet isn't really deep enough for narcosis to be that bad (even for me) but it's deep enough to concentrate any contaminant in the gas (eg. CO).
 
You were sick before you entered the water? I've had my sea sickness affect my dive. I've only been sea sick three times, but one time the sickness carried into the water with me, and I got weak as hell, stomach all torn up. My other thought is, had you used this tank before? You said it was new, perhaps bad gas. If this is your first use of this tank, i'd bleed it down and take a look inside. I've seen rodents in tanks before.
 
Or could it be to a culmination of other various stress factors that added up to cause this?

It is suprising how little it can take to tip the scales. A little bit of vertigo coupled with a bit of CO2 retention can do strange things even at 70 feet. That said I would still check for contaminated gas.
 
So far, sounds like everyones in agreement. Recheck the gas...
 
A few questions I would ask myself:

1. Was I absolutely sure I was diving EANx 30?
2. Did I take any sea sickness medication prior to the dive?
3. How dehydrated was I?
4. Was I breathing harder than I normally do, for whatever reason on my descent?

If the answers to these provide no insight, I'd want to know more about my brand new tank. Probably would want the air analyzed. Any LDS can provide this service through the same service that tests their compressor air.

Mike
 
BTW. Just got back from seeing Inception.

My question is:

At the end of the movie, was it a dream, or was it real?

Mike
 
Possibility of CO2 Buildup from strenuous conditions?
 
A few questions I would ask myself:

1. Was I absolutely sure I was diving EANx 30?

2. Did I take any sea sickness medication prior to the dive?

3. How dehydrated was I?

4. Was I breathing harder than I normally do, for whatever reason on my descent?

If the answers to these provide no insight, I'd want to know more about my brand new tank. Probably would want the air analyzed. Any LDS can provide this service through the same service that tests their compressor air.

Mike

1: We analyzed it with the centers analyzer. And they have a premixed 30% blend. Does that guarantee it though? No, hence my desire to do so again with another device and check for other conatminants.

2: No, as I said, I've never had seasickenss before.

3: I found after the fact that I downed 2 iced teas at lunch and a giant soda at the movies.

4: During the descent, no. Only after the onset of the other symptoms.

5. Inception
Yes, it was definately a movie to be watched.
 

Back
Top Bottom