You make the call...

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Nomad

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Divemaster
Messages
241
Reaction score
2
Location
Currently - Texas
# of dives
100 - 199
Plan your Dive, Dive your Plan.
Last November I dove on the Duane with Ocean Diver's out of Key Largo, near MM 101 (As a side note, I highly recommend Ocean Diver's.). Ocean Diver's required an AOW C-card and they required that my logbook show at least 10 ocean dives in the last year.

My buddy was a "pick-up" from the boat. He seemed capable of "talking the talk" pretty well. Other then that, I had no knowledge of his actual skill level. This was our first dive of the day.

Our dive plan was as follows:
We will descend using the line.
After arriving at the deck of the Duane, we will stay together while we explore.
We will monitor each other’s air consumption.
We will turn the dive when the first person reaches 2/3 air remaining.
We will ascend using the same line.
We will execute a 3-5 minute safety stop.
The dive can be called at any time, by either diver, without question, simply by flashing a thumbs-up sign. (I believe that it is imperative to establish this rule with any dive buddy.)
After discussing our Dive Plan, we practiced a few basic hand signals to reduce the likelihood of confusion underwater.
During the safety briefing, it was stated that there would be no decompression dives.

As soon as the safety briefing concluded, my buddy and I splashed. The rest of the divers on the boat were still gearing up.
The current was completely non-existent. At around 25 feet, the haze opened up and the wreck of the U.S.S. Duane suddenly appeared below us. It was absolutely amazing.
We followed the line to the deck. The line we descended was located midship on the Duane. I signaled "Which way?" My buddy pointed forward. I agreed, and we started a slow swim. We both maintained good contact with each other, never straying more than a few feet away. We reached the bow, looked around for a little while, then turned and headed aft. We each checked each others air consumption. I was surprised to realize that his air consumption was fairly consistent with my own. (Our second dive was 85 minutes on Molasses reef. We both surfaced with 1/3 tank remaining.)
We both continued to follow the Dive Plan. We reached the back of the boat and continued to explore. The rest of the divers from the boat had joined us by this point.
Suddenly, out of nowhere, a current swept in. It was moving at about 1 to 1.5 knots, toward the back of the Duane. Although neither of us had yet reached 2/3, I suggested we turn the dive. My buddy agreed. We were surrounded by other divers at this point, and they all turned with us.
There were a few moments of confusion as we all started fighting the current to return to the ascent line. I was breathing hard, but we were all making headway.
As I fought the current, I realized I was racing my NDL. I watched the NDL continue to count down on my computer while I worked my way towards the ascent line. The "oh crap!" moment occurred when I visually measured the remaining distance against my present speed and I realized that I wasn’t going to make it. I am a strong swimmer, but it was apparent that my NDL timer would reach zero before I would be able to reach the line and begin my ascent. I had less than a minute left, and I was at least 2 minutes away from the ascent line.
While visually assessing distance to the line, I momentarily stopped swimming. This allowed my buddy to get slightly ahead of me. As a result, for the first time this dive, I could not immediately get his attention. (I learned later that in the confusion he had momentarily lost sight of me. When he saw someone ahead of him with blue fins, he thought he was swimming hard to catch up with me.)

My options:
  1. Stray from the Dive Plan and do a Decompression Dive. I can continue along the deck until I reach the ascent line and then add my decompression obligation to my ascent time.
  2. Stray from the Dive Plan and ascend 10-15 feet until my NDL increases by the 1-2 minutes I will need to reach the ascent line without earning a decompression obligation.
What would you do? No fair saying "I wouldn't ever allow myself to be in this situation..."
 
It is no problem to have your computer go into deco for a minute or two. A slow ascent would take care of any deco obligation. Stick with the plan, IMHO.
 
I agree with Dennis... It wouldn't have been more than a minute or two of Deco, and a super slow ascent with a 1/2 depth level stop would be wise anyway, so your computer would have probably let you off with just a 3 minute safety stop anyway... 5 minutes at the most no?
 
Assuming the current wasn't worse up 10 feet or so, angle up to meet your buddy at the line but above him by 10 feet or so.

You are already separated, so being separated vertically as well as horizontally isn't really a change in the plan assuming reasonable vis so you have him in sight the whole time. If he hasn't caught sight of you, you can go down and get his attention at the line if he never looks back, or, as you are above and behind you will need to watch for the first time he looks back to find you and try and get his attention. Bang on the tank, whatever.

In really bad vis I would move up to the limit of vis to keep him in sight and meet at the line assuming I couldn't catch up.
 
howarde:
I agree with Dennis... It wouldn't have been more than a minute or two of Deco, and a super slow ascent with a 1/2 depth level stop would be wise anyway, so your computer would have probably let you off with just a 3 minute safety stop anyway... 5 minutes at the most no?

That is exactly right howarde. By the time you get to even 30' you would be out of deco.
 
howarde:
I agree with Dennis... It wouldn't have been more than a minute or two of Deco, and a super slow ascent with a 1/2 depth level stop would be wise anyway, so your computer would have probably let you off with just a 3 minute safety stop anyway... 5 minutes at the most no?
Yep - but why is this question coming from a DM? :confused:
 
DandyDon:
Yep - but why is this question coming from a DM? :confused:

My motivation was to stimulate discussion. No need to poke me in the eye with a sharp stick... Geez.
 

Back
Top Bottom