This thread began with questions about Ixcalak and diving with XTC. I know zero about Majahual and actually don't care for the place that much. Too built up and carters to the cruise boats. I am sure there are good shops there that can get you out to chinchorro weather permitting. From my end Ixcalak is a better choice since I like the laid back feel of the place and if you are going there to dive chinchorro then its a good place to hang out till a window opens and you can get out. Diving in Ixcalak is OK. You will not see crowds like you would in Majahual.
As to who has better access I would say the same. Chinchorro is a big area though now its zoned so the diving is restricted to certain areas. Over the years I have made four or so trips out there (camping out on Cayo Lobos twice) and I was not that impressed. Not virgin diving by any stretch.
Thanks for the speedy response.
Not knowing much about the area, getting info from knowledgeable divers that have insights is invaluable.
We're planning on diving Mahahual, and maybe a day in Xcalak. Hopefully between those 2 locations, we can secure one trip to Chinchirro. If not, then we'll just have to make do with whats available. Should be a great trip regardless.
I think only 2 cruise ships are scheduled to be in port (Tuesday and Thursday) for the week we are there, so hopefully it will be a little more laid back.
On a side note, I've heard that Mahahual is trying to get a theme or water park built. The cruise lines are trying to get ports to invest in more and more attractions and those that don't, will lose out to the ports that do. It's a shame to see pristine areas gobbled up by the cruise lines, but I must admit, that's where I first got a chance to visit Mahahual. The cruise ship money is definitely a two-edge sword.