Ana:
Remove ALL the air from the BC, breath the reg. while looking at the gauge to assure there is air in the bottle and the valve is truly open, look where are you going to jump and splash. If something is weird stop around 10 feet or so and figure things out. As long as you have air (which you assured before the splash) it is a lot less hectic at 10 feet than at the surface, especially if it is choppy.
This sounds like a recipe for getting separated to me.
I understand why bobbing endlessly on the surface is annoying to a lot of people. However, it is important to keep in mind that most diving problems arise at the surface, not underwater. Granted, in a perfect world, we would all do a thorough buddy check on the boat prior to entry. But especially in high seas, it's just not very practical because folks are anxious to get off the boat and/or nauseous. Also, reading about malfunctioning BCs and divers plummeting to depth and death, to me the regrouping and final check on the surface is the most important step of the dive.
Yes, one could ask why there is a need to regroup, given that the divers just did that a minute before on the boat. But I think regrouping makes sense in this case because while it may seem all you do is stepping off a ladder, in reality you are transitioning from land to ocean, you are changing elements during that short step, entering an environment with completely different conditions.
Or, as John Lennon once phrased it, after he got his AOW cert: "It's one small step for a diver, but a giant leap for the ones left behind..."
Wait, maybe it wasn't John Lennon....
